Sleepy, this is not trival at all.
I don't think you are commitment phobic but I see God working in those situations. Let me ask you a few questions here.
1. Are either of these men born again Christians?
2. Are they using thier lives to serve Christ?
3. Are you wanting to serve Christ with your whole life?
Sleepy, I was not prepared to marry (let alone date) my husband if he was not a born again, active Christian, I would not have wasted my time. I gave my whole life to Christ and that means I will serve Him with my whole life. I did not want to be in a marriage where only one of us goes to Church and the other complains about going or just does not go. My life is not my own. It is only based on seeing his faith in action did I consider a relationship with him. Without that we had nothing to build a relationship on. Sleepy are you willing to settle for metorocraty, second best? Because if either of these men do not live a life serving God then that is what you are settling for and personally it is not worth it. I see too many Christian women who married their husband who do not believe and the struggles they go thru are tremendous. Read some of the post in the prayer requests.
Stop focusing on what you want with your life but only think about what He wants for you. God makes your life better not men. Tell God how you feel about wanting a relationship but then give it to Him to find you a mate, He will find someone better then you ever will.