Welcome!

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.

SignUp Now!
  • Welcome to Talk Jesus Christian Forums

    Celebrating 20 Years!

    A bible based, Jesus Christ centered community.

    Register Log In

Passion question?

cuprunsovr

Member
Joined
Feb 27, 2006
Messages
54
Last weekend my wife and I were watching "The Passion" and she was asking questions throughout that I answered as best I could, but one stumped me. I have a theory but wanted to see if anyone here may know.

If you have scene it you know that throughout the movie Jesus sees things that take him back to various things that have happened in the previous hours, days, etc. Near teh end of the movie Jesus is nearing Galgatha, falls with the cross from his exhaustion in sort of a public area when the Romans and others begin to beat him furtherand mock him. A woman appears pleading for them to stop, and when they do she draws close to him offers him a towel and a cup to drink from. The woman is shown just before this with her daughter in kind of an arbitrary scene comforting her daughter to the coming mob. My wife's question was who this woman was from scripture? Anyone know?

My theory is this either IS the Samaritan women from Jacob's well, or is just a woman placed in to provoke a "cut scene' back to the story of the Samaritan woman but with the cut back scene dropped for some reason. If you watch the way the movie is done start to finish this would make sense (especially given the drink she offers), but as it is it just seems like there is an explanation left out when Jesus gives her "the stare" that usually leads to a background story.

Anyway not earth shaking stuff , just figured someone may know or I missed something in the gospel accounts that would better explain.

Be Blessed
 
Well I looked in Matthew Mark Luke and John and did not see that scene (so to speak)

In Luke Chapter 23 v 27 There it speaks of woman following watching crying out.. Still though no reference to a woman giving Him water..

From what I can tell that scene is of artistic (sp) nature.


Joyfully ~ Jlu
 
That may have been refering to the Veil of Veronica, which isn't in the Bible and is just tradition. Veronica was supposed to have wiped Jesus' face off with a towel and his face's image was imprinted on it, like the Shroud of Turin.
It's been a while since I saw the Passion and I only vaguely remember the part you're talking about, though, it could just be the filmmakers using artistic licence.
~ Jack
 
Back
Top