Just wondered if people ever encounter sarcastic atheists...
Hi, Lanolin. I THOUGHT I felt my ears burning. (hee-hee)
Seriously, I have been that sarcastic atheist. Speaking for myself (who is all I CAN speak for), when interacting with people who I know to be religious, I reserve my sarcasm (which can be venomous and withering, I admit) for only two situations:
1. When my correspondent turns a conversation into a personal attack (either against me or against some other participant who did not initiate any hostile behavior).
2. OR when a correspondent casually makes some morally reprehensible statement.
I know these rules don’t necessarily safeguard against ALL bad behavior. I have met some atheists who take it as a “personal attack” when you tell them they are going to Hell. To me, that’s no attack at all. If there is a God and I don’t abide his will, of course, I’m going to Hell. Naturally.
I don’t read statements like, “Muslims are going to hell,” or, “Homosexuals are going to hell,” as morally wrong for the same reason. However, I DO confront people who say things like, “America is a Christian nation and Muslims had better convert or shut up,” (one I have heard) or, “Homos should either kill themselves or be killed,”(sadly, another I have actually heard). When I confront people who say such things, I feel that simply saying, “That’s disgusting and wrong,” feels inadequate, and may not convey enough of the outrage I sense at such reprehensible opinions. My options at that point are few. I can either say, “That’s REALL, REALLY, REALLY… …REALLY WRONG,” I can resort to plain insult and name-calling (which communicates my anger, but does no more to explain WHAT I find so objectionable), or I can analyze and ridicule. This last option is, for me anyway, much more satisfying and, unlike the other two options, offers an opportunity to illustrate WHY the idea I am objecting to is so wrong.
You and I have interacted a few times here recently, and I hope I haven’t come off as very sarcastic. At least I don’t recall anything in those conversations which caused me to take out my “[explitive] YOU BAG.” And I’m pretty sure you’d know if I had. Not to toot my own horn, but once I got Mahatma Gandhi to come after me with a fire axe.
:wink: