Pride come before a fall...
I was extremely reluctant to write a critique of this work, firstly because I hate criticizing anyones work and secondly because I don't write well or easily, so it was hard for me to do this on both counts. But having once witnessed a close personal friends life cut short due to demonic activity. Then having had my own struggles with demons that inhabited my body, as a young Christian, and the torment they caused me. I felt it would be wrong for me to keep silent on this issue.
Can Christians Be Demonized?
By: Hank Hanegraaf
“Over the years, I have read a wide variety of stories that claim to support the notion that Christians can be demonized.”
Let's look the first sentence, '... I have read a variety of stories...' What does this tell us about the author? “...I have read...” suggests the author is a theorist, someone who has no practical experience of such things. The next part of the sentence, '...a wide variety of stories...' Suggests the author believed he was reading fiction, no doubt there were testimonies of people who were delivered from demonic oppression. The author has reduced these testimonies to the level of comic book stories. I'm not sure whether this is unwitting or deliberate mockery, but it is mockery nevertheless.
I would also suggest that the author had a preconceived position before he ever read any books on deliverance ministry. He had already decided they were wrong.
(It might be worth noting at this point that some theologians don't believe in the Baptism in the Holy Spirit or spiritual gifts but believe these things belong to another era. And anyone who does believe in these things is deluded and cultist)
Lets now have a look at the statement, 'They greatly overestimate the power and province of Satan.' There are two possible positions that Christians can fall into here both of which are wrong. One is to disregard the realm of Satan and demons and take the view they don't have much influence on Christians today.
The opposite and equally wrong view is as the author says to, '... overestimate the power... of Satan.' People who do, tend to see demons in everything and everywhere.
Before we get any deeper into analyzing Mr Henegraaf argument. I think it might be good to have a brief look at what Our Lord, Jesus said in regard to demons and what our response to them should be. Matthew 10:8 says, “ Heal the sick, raise the dead, cleanse those who have leprosy, drive out demons.” And Mark 16:17 says, “ And these signs will accompany those who believe. In my name they will drive out demons...” So both Matthew and Mark record that Jesus said believers should drive out demons. So deliverance ministry is something that our Lord Jesus has legitimized.
“In the end, they all have one thing in common: Some deliverance ministers make a more valiant attempt than others to provide a biblical basis for the contention that a Christian can be inhabited by a demon. Inevitably, however, Scripture itself undermines their stories.
First, Christ Himself precluded the possibility that a Christian could be inhabited by demons. Using the illustration of a house, Jesus asks, "How can anyone enter a strong man's house and carry off his possessions unless he first ties up the strong man?" (Matthew 12:29). In the case of a demon-possessed person, the strong man is obviously the devil. In a Spirit-indwelt believer, however, the strong man is God. The fore of Christ's argument leads inexorably to the conclusion that, in order for demons to possess believers, they would first have to bind the one who occupies them - namely God Himself!”
The problem here is that most people who have a demon got it before they were born again. So that argument immediate falls to the ground. The need for deliverance ministry is most often a consequence of what happened to people before they were born again.
(Deliverance ministry should be part of being an evangelist. Unfortunately this isn't always the case. So the demons have to dealt with after the person becomes a Christian. Some have suggested that when a person is born again that process should automatically deal with the demons.
In practice it often doesn't, but continual exposure to Spirit led worship and Spirit anointed preaching/teaching will drive the demon to the surface. Then there will be an opportunity to drive them out. The reason some Christians are disturbed in Holy Spirit led worship is because the demons within them are reacting negatively to the Worship.)
For arguments sake lets suppose that a demon tries to take up residence in a believers body/flesh. Does it have to bind Almighty God to do this?
I can't believe I'm even rising to answer such an utterly silly question. But since Mr Hanegraaf's put it up as an argument against deliverance ministry we are going to have to look at it. And I would start by asking: Does a believer have to bind God the Holy Spirit before he sins?
No as believers we have a choice as to whom we serve. Romans 6:16 Don't you know that when you offer yourselves to someone to obey him as slaves, you are slaves to the one whom you obey—whether you are slaves to sin, which leads to death, or to obedience, which leads to righteousness?
We can quench and grieve the Holy Spirit through the choices we make. If
we choose to sin we suffer loss our faith wanes and the influence of the Holy Spirit in our lives becomes less. That is a very basic Bible proposition. If a believer continues to give in to temptation and does not turn in true repentance to God, then the influence of God in his life and his faith starts to become less and less. The demon however, is enjoying greater and greater influence over the believers life. And since sin and Satan are synonymous it become a very simple matter for the demon of say, lust to enter into that part of the flesh/sinful nature of the believer and take up residence there. It should be remembered that the body has not been fully redeemed yet according to 1 Corinthians 15:54 For this corruptible must put on incorruption, and this mortal must put on immortality. I think we all know it was sin that caused corruption & mortality. So until our Lord Jesus changes our condition our minds and bodies are still vulnerable to the enemy, and a demon can go anywhere sin and disease can go.
I have personally known people who died prematurely through demonic oppression. There have been Christian families torn apart, lives shattered, Christians in torment, some have committed suicide all these instances could and can, often, be prevented by deliverance ministry. This is the reason I will argue strongly to defend deliverance ministry. It has been and continues to be for some people, both Christian and none Christian a matter of life or death.
Furthermore, I discovered an equally airtight argument against Christian demonization in the Gospel of John. The Jews once again were accusing Jesus of being demon-possessed. Rather than circumvent their accusations., Jesus condescends to reach out to His accusers with reason. The essence of His argument is "I am not possessed by a demon" because "I honor my Father" (John 8:49). The point is impossible to miss: Being demon-possessed and honoring God are mutually exclusive categories.
There would be something to this argument if Christians had always honoured God with their bodies, but this simply isn't true historically or otherwise.
Take for instance 1 Corinthians 6: 15-20; Do you not know that your bodies are members of Christ himself? Shall I then take the members of Christ and unite them with a prostitute? Never! Do you not know that he who unites himself with a prostitute is one with her in body? For it is said, "The two will become one flesh." But he who unites himself with the Lord is one with him in spirit.
Flee from sexual immorality. All other sins a man commits are outside his body, but he who sins sexually sins against his own body. Do you not know that your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit, who is in you, whom you have received from God? You are not your own; you were bought at a price. Therefore honour God with your body.
It is a misnomer to suggest that Christians always honour God with their bodies. History and practice proves that they don't. That is why the Apostle Paul has to exhort the Corinthians to honour God with their bodies. The apostle Paul would never have exhorted the Christians at Corinth to honour God with their bodies if there was no need to do so. So it would be reasonable to conclude that some of them had not been honouring God with their bodies.
In the final analysis it's down to a question of choices, 'whom will you serve.' (Romans 6:16)
Instead, The principle is foolproof. If you are a follower of Christ, the King Himself indwells you. And you can rest assured that "the One who is in you is greater than the one who is in the world"(1 John 4:4)
This is a true statement, if someone is sold out for Jesus, then they have the full benefit of this great scripture.
“the consistent teaching of the Bible is that Christians cannot be controlled against their wills through demonic inhabitation.”
That is also a true statement. The only problem I have with it is, a Christian who previously didn't have a demon and now has one, chose to go that way. That is what happens when someone consistently yields to the temptation of a demon.
“Finally, Scripture does not contain a single credible example of a demonized believer.”
The answer to this final statement by Mr Hanegraaf depends on ones faith, revelation and the personal integrity before God. The key to revelation is humility. To approach the Bible without utter dependence on the one who inspired the Bible, the Holy Spirit, is wrong. Unfortunately, many in their pride have not learned this lesson yet and still think they are able, by reason of their own intelligence, to figure out God and the Bible. This is why there is so much division in the body of Christ. It is man trying to do God's work for Him, instead of allowing God to do His work through man. This always leads to the sin of division. In John 7:18 Jesus said, He who speaks on his own does so to gain honour for himself, but he who works for the honour of the one who sent him is a man of truth; there is nothing false about him. That is the key to successful ministry, to deny ones self and speak only from the revelation we receive from God. If we did that a lot of the doctrinal arguments between Christians would just fall away.
If anyone has a genuine need to know about deliverance ministry remember, “ God opposes the proud but gives grace to the humble, Humble your selves under God's mighty hand..”. 1 Pet.5.5-6 And “ Ask and it will be given to you; seek; and you will find; knock and the door will be opened to you.” Matt.7.7.
It goes without saying that moving in deliverance ministry without the Baptism in the Holy Spirit and His gifts is nigh on impossible!