Welcome!

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.

SignUp Now!
  • Welcome to Talk Jesus Christian Forums

    Celebrating 20 Years!

    A bible based, Jesus Christ centered community.

    Register Log In

Greetings -- A Freindly Atheist Who Wants to Know: Why Christ?

Well, to me these questions are fundamental to why I don't accept Christianity. Maybe God is pressing me to ask them? It's also my understanding that born agains have an understood duty to evangelize, so I thought here I would find people who wouldn't mind answering some of my questions.

If I may. I think an overview of why we as humans are all here is in order to possibly get a smidge of understanding as to what is happening.

First of all God wanted children AKA (sons) so he went through the trouble of creating all that the eye can behold and ear hear etc.... Then he forms a man and puts him in an environment that should have been perfect, as the man was with God daily and walking and talking with him, but the man knew nothing other than what God told him. The man somehow becomes lonely even in the presence of God so God makes him a mate (Eve). At the same time in this garden there is a serpent (devil) whom God placed there as well.
When the devil who has a job to deceive humans, deceived Eve then Adam listened to Eve instead of God to not take of the fruit of the tree of the Knowledge of good and evil
they both had there eyes opened and became as God. The devil and God both said so. Weird but true. The knowledge of good and evil is essential to being like God, he knows how to control it and does, however man is driven to destroy himself through knowing and doing evil as God will not allow men to have never ending life. First 4,000 years of history nut shelled. Now God who knew he would send a Spirit known to man as Jesus was born as a man outside what is called a carnal mind which causes a person to believe that they are their own God. Adam was made that way then fell and all men after that were condemned to possess that same mind which is separation from God mentally and spiritually. Now Jesus who was the physical Son of God and Mary in the flesh was born outside the curse of carnality which allowed him to be sinless during his earthly time. The curse is passed from father to child.
He was in constant communion with God his Father the whole time with about an 18 hour exception at the end of his life. He became a sacrifice for sin of ALL MEN and
thus God highly exalted him to the position of a God as the Son of God, the first born from among the dead.
Now is the time when God chooses who he will allow to know these things and be saved as he is the decider of those who receive salvation. Thing is that all men no matter what religion or atheism belief or no belief they have now will eventually come to know the love of God it's just a matter of time because as I said in opening he wants children
and everything that is being done is to perfect children that will be able to possess the capacity of God their Father. Jesus was the first and is the example as he was obedient
to his Father, also yours spiritually, and was resurrected unto the status as a Son who possesses the fullness of his Father. This knowledge that God gives to those whom he chooses is what drives us to be like Christ Jesus as we are Hoping, having faith that God who cannot lie has promised Eternal life to all men before he created the world. If
you have partook of humanity then it is a certainty that you will also take part in the process of salvation. Which will require the death of your carnality so that you may see
God as responsible for all calamity/evil that enters into your life and be able to comprehend that he is developing you to grab hold of his likeness in that you will never do evil
to any child of God once granted the status of a son of God with unlimited abilities that your imagination cannot yet comprehend. Truth be told you were promised this eternal life before you became a man by God himself. You, in spirit, came out from him and shall return to him a fully matured glorious son of God when he decides to start working on you, your life will be turned upside down and you will be seen as crazy by your friends, but yet that day will be the best day of your life on earth as reality has then set in.

Tried to keep it short but nut shelling the Bible isn't easy. Most cannot see the forest for the trees and they get even further side tracked by examining the bark on the trees.

And yes all of this is in the Bible but alot of it is hidden from the eyes of man. When they read it they do not understand it and it is meant to keep those out whom are not
chosen to participate at this time.
 
A person who hates what is wicked and clings to what is good Rom 12:9 is after God's heart and God does draw near to and makes Himself known to such a person James 4:8. He judges such a person at a depth Jer 17:9-11 as only He can. He reveals Jesus as Lord and Saviour to such a person Matt 16:16-17. Hence He can and does make the statement that Jesus is the way and the truth John 14:6.

Does this mean that if you are good, and God sees that you are Good in your heart, God will reveal Jesus as Lord and Saviour to you?

God is light with no darkness in Him at all 1 John 1:5. We cannot be in an environment of sin and expect Him to be there with His full Glory and presence too. Free will would instantly cease to exist.

Abraham and Moses still had Free will? Or did they not have free will.
 
If I may. I think an overview of why we as humans are all here is in order to possibly get a smidge of understanding as to what is happening.

First of all God wanted children AKA (sons) so he went through the trouble of creating all that the eye can behold and ear hear etc.... Then he forms a man and puts him in an environment that should have been perfect, as the man was with God daily and walking and talking with him, but the man knew nothing other than what God told him. The man somehow becomes lonely even in the presence of God so God makes him a mate (Eve). At the same time in this garden there is a serpent (devil) whom God placed there as well.
When the devil who has a job to deceive humans, deceived Eve then Adam listened to Eve instead of God to not take of the fruit of the tree of the Knowledge of good and evil
they both had there eyes opened and became as God. The devil and God both said so. Weird but true. The knowledge of good and evil is essential to being like God, he knows how to control it and does, however man is driven to destroy himself through knowing and doing evil as God will not allow men to have never ending life. First 4,000 years of history nut shelled. Now God who knew he would send a Spirit known to man as Jesus was born as a man outside what is called a carnal mind which causes a person to believe that they are their own God. Adam was made that way then fell and all men after that were condemned to possess that same mind which is separation from God mentally and spiritually. Now Jesus who was the physical Son of God and Mary in the flesh was born outside the curse of carnality which allowed him to be sinless during his earthly time. The curse is passed from father to child.
He was in constant communion with God his Father the whole time with about an 18 hour exception at the end of his life. He became a sacrifice for sin of ALL MEN and
thus God highly exalted him to the position of a God as the Son of God, the first born from among the dead.
Now is the time when God chooses who he will allow to know these things and be saved as he is the decider of those who receive salvation. Thing is that all men no matter what religion or atheism belief or no belief they have now will eventually come to know the love of God it's just a matter of time because as I said in opening he wants children
and everything that is being done is to perfect children that will be able to possess the capacity of God their Father. Jesus was the first and is the example as he was obedient
to his Father, also yours spiritually, and was resurrected unto the status as a Son who possesses the fullness of his Father. This knowledge that God gives to those whom he chooses is what drives us to be like Christ Jesus as we are Hoping, having faith that God who cannot lie has promised Eternal life to all men before he created the world. If
you have partook of humanity then it is a certainty that you will also take part in the process of salvation. Which will require the death of your carnality so that you may see
God as responsible for all calamity/evil that enters into your life and be able to comprehend that he is developing you to grab hold of his likeness in that you will never do evil
to any child of God once granted the status of a son of God with unlimited abilities that your imagination cannot yet comprehend. Truth be told you were promised this eternal life before you became a man by God himself. You, in spirit, came out from him and shall return to him a fully matured glorious son of God when he decides to start working on you, your life will be turned upside down and you will be seen as crazy by your friends, but yet that day will be the best day of your life on earth as reality has then set in.

Tried to keep it short but nut shelling the Bible isn't easy. Most cannot see the forest for the trees and they get even further side tracked by examining the bark on the trees.

And yes all of this is in the Bible but alot of it is hidden from the eyes of man. When they read it they do not understand it and it is meant to keep those out whom are not
chosen to participate at this time.


Thank you for the thoughtful remarks, Samson 2020.

I don’t recall having interacted here with you ere now. If that is so, I’ll paint four you a brief sketch where I come from on Christianity’s proposition.

I no longer believe there is good evidence to think any god exists. This is a departure from my former state of belief, but the transition was not a drastic one. I was raised taught the world was created by God and ran according to his rules. I never felt any particular “spirit” or “presence” of it, but for most of my life I chalked this up to some failing on my part, one among many. I just slowly grew out of that worldview through experience.



I am keenly interested in religion and, in particular, Christianity because (A) I have no proof there is nothing to it and, if it is indeed true in any real sense, I had better come to terms with it, the LAST thing I want to do is live in some form of denial about how the world really works; and (B) even if there is no “truth” in it, I can’t deny it is a main spring built into the machinery of how many of the humans with whom I share the world operate. I think intimate understanding of that mechanism serves my own individual interests as well as those of our broader community.

I find the Christian principle of redemption exceedingly meritorious, even brilliant. And revolutionary for the era in which it was conceived. Since before the time of Hamurabi’s Code humans have made an absolutely fetish of justice and social order. But have very little in the way of offering failed, fallen humans avenues via which to redeem themselves. Towards that end, I think Christianity evinces flashes of absolute genius.

If I believed in the existence of God and the reality of Christianity, there are several things I would find disagreeable about them (and, indeed, things about Christianity disagreeable even in the absence of God). I’m happy to recite my litany of complaints. (They’re very run of the mill, as you might imagine.) But I think my three most salient differences with Christian doctrine are:

1. I reject the very notion of human sacrifice, for any reason, on principle. If I had been at Calvary I would have seen it as my moral duty to thwart the Crucifixion, no matter who Jesus was. And I would consider failing to put a stop to it a great moral defeat on my part, one from which I doubt I could ever fully recover.

2. The principle of vicarious redemption is unjust and impracticable. I cannot blame another for anything Adam or Eve or anyone else ever did. No act of repentance or sacrifice on the part of any person can offset my own responsibility for any of my own wrongs. And (most especially) if in the unjust case that Jesus’s suffering can assuage the guilt of the sins of all mankind, then my own sacrifice ought to be worth SOMEthing. I don’t ask to save an entire generation, nor even just one nation of people. If I knew, for certain, sacrificing myself could in any way spare the suffering of my two children, I would offer myself up with a smile on my lips and a song in my heart. I think I would do it for some arbitrary number of perfect strangers, even. But I can’t. Can I?

3. I once was convinced that morality, as taught in the Bible, was sophisticated, enlightened and infallibly just. The more I live, the more I become convinced it is quite an uninteresting instance of “carrot and stick” morality, based entirely upon imagined (and probably imaginary) rewards and punishments. These can be very effective inducements to moral behavior, but my children are not yet out of their teens and they both outgrew this very unsophisticated, transactional ethical code years ago.

I spend a good bit of my available time reading the Bible. All that any such study elicits in me is a deeper appreciation of (what I find to be) its shortcomings. I cherish many favorite verses (All time #1 Greatest Hit is Gen 2:15. Let me know if you’d like to talk about it. And there is no entrance of any villain in all of literature as awesome as Job 2:2!) But I have a long and constantly growing list of verses I find troubling, at best. I think one verse which embodies more of what I find wrongheaded about the entire premise of Christianity is Rom 11:32 “For God has bound everyone over to disobedience so that he may have mercy on them all.”

I love my children. I am told God loves me more than I love them. I cannot fathom any outrage for which I would not forgive my children. I am told God is willing to forgive me, but if, and only if… (X, Y, Z). Rom 11:32 tells me God made us all AND made us flawed IN ORDER TO forgive us. The ultimate self-licking ice cream cone. And he expects something, anything, from me before he is willing to condescend to it.

I’m afraid I don’t find any bit of it very enticing. But, recall, nor do I find its reality convincing.
 
We have concrete evidence of God by observing intelligent design in all creations Rom 1:20.

Theologically, If you had to read the bible from start to finish you will see that God tries to remain as isolated as is possible. For me it all points to Him wanting a place where true free will can exist.

If God was your neighbor, you would always be on your best behavior or want to run away to another part of the universe. Earth affords each of us a period to grasp who we are and for Him to grasp who we choose to be. All in relation to our hatred or love of what is wicked.

A person who hates what is wicked and clings to what is good Rom 12:9 is after God's heart and God does draw near to and makes Himself known to such a person James 4:8. He judges such a person at a depth Jer 17:9-11 as only He can. He reveals Jesus as Lord and Saviour to such a person Matt 16:16-17. Hence He can and does make the statement that Jesus is the way and the truth John 14:6.

His people do hear His voice John 10:27 and they know His peace Phil 4:7.

God is light with no darkness in Him at all 1 John 1:5. We cannot be in an environment of sin and expect Him to be there with His full Glory and presence too. Free will would instantly cease to exist.

God is for an environment where people are free to be Buddhist, atheistic, agnostic, Catholic, Protestant, good, evil, semi sweet, etc.



Firstly understand that ''ONLY'' God is perfectly good Mark 10:18. No angel in heaven, no human that will be with God will ever be as perfectly good as God. We will always have some flaws.

The devil's flaws warranted removal. We can tell God did the right thing simply by observing what the devil is responsible for in our time.

God draws a line between one sold out to evil and someone not. As only He can Jer 17:9-11. Some will simply never truly repent of their sins. Some love the darkness more then they hate it. John 3:17 This is the verdict: Light has come into the world, but people loved darkness instead of light because their deeds were evil..

Angels had free will just as we do. The evidence points to an absolutely amazing God!! One that honors true free will.


"If God was your neighbor, you would always be on your best behavior or want to run away to another part of the universe. "

Forgive me speaking out of turn.

I could think of hardly anything more entertaining than the prospect of having God as a neighbor. I doubt I would be on my "best" behavior. Why should I? He already knows all of the very worst I do. I would be on "good" behavior, as I am with all my neighbors. Still, I can't shake the feeling he'd very quickly find some excuse to move to another neighborhood. And I'll wager he'd be DEEPLY disappointed with the price he'd get for his house.
 
1. I reject the very notion of human sacrifice, for any reason, on principle. If I had been at Calvary I would have seen it as my moral duty to thwart the Crucifixion, no matter who Jesus was. And I would consider failing to put a stop to it a great moral defeat on my part, one from which I doubt I could ever fully recover.

You must consider that if God raised Jesus from the dead then what was it for God to have him die in the first place? The real feat was for the faith that Jesus had in his Father to actually raise him up, but since he had already raised up Lazarus even his faith had been strengthened. And you sound just like Peter who did not want Jesus to be taken and crucified and was rebuked by Jesus for not loving the things that be of God. Thats what we call SELF PRESERVATION, and self must die for the betterment of ALL.
2. The principle of vicarious redemption is unjust and impracticable. I cannot blame another for anything Adam or Eve or anyone else ever did. No act of repentance or sacrifice on the part of any person can offset my own responsibility for any of my own wrongs. And (most especially) if in the unjust case that Jesus’s suffering can assuage the guilt of the sins of all mankind, then my own sacrifice ought to be worth SOMEthing.
The body of MAN is as grass. It is the spirit of man that God is concerned with, to mature it to the point he can trust it to do no harm. Indeed it is the fear of death that causes us to be sinners as we believe we only have 1 life and we need to make the most of it.
Your sacrifice will be worth something to God and you will gladly lay it down when he requires you to. "Precious in the sight of the Lord is the DEATH of ALL his saints." As to your not liking the way God did things its just simply a misunderstanding of Gods intentions for all and someday it will become clear that all suffering was worth the price for the reward attained. Jesus as an example has been appointed as the King of all creation in heaven and earth, angels included, and has attained to the level of a God (one who is spirit that cannot die and can give life to others).
Gods decision to conclude ALL men in unbelief so that he may have mercy upon ALL men offends you? God wanted to make salvation a gift so not one person could say I EARNED IT SO I'M BETTER THAN ANOTHER. Your own wrongs as you see them are evil in your eyes but what do you suppose God would say? That you had free will to do what you did or he made you so that you would fulfill whatever part he had ordained for you to fulfill as a man?
Forgiving oneself is easier when you know why you did what you did, help mature another. The real problem is the fact that you enjoyed it thats where your sacrifice will come to bear when your own selfish carnality is required to die in the face of the same evil you relished in comes directly at you and you must love it thou it kills you, knowing it is God that wields the blade.
I love my children. I am told God loves me more than I love them. I cannot fathom any outrage for which I would not forgive my children. I am told God is willing to forgive me, but if, and only if… (X, Y, Z)

Free gifts do not come with exceptions. But position within this spiritual kingdom does make requirements of you.
And who you call your kids are actually his as are you. You are the father of their flesh, but God is the Father of their spirit. "And without the spirit the body is dead."

If there is any 1 thing more important to understand than another bring it up and lets see where it goes.

I personally contribute my calling from a small book written by an evangelist from South America, can't say it was anything special but God saw it as the one piece I needed.
But you know the story...... GOD works in mysterious ways!!
 
Does this mean that if you are good, and God sees that you are Good in your heart, God will reveal Jesus as Lord and Saviour to you?
If you are good, you will hate what is wicked. If you hate what is wicked you will repent. If you repent truthfully OT or NT God will not reject you. In the NT, yes, God will reveal Jesus as Lord to you.

1 Cor 12:3 Nobody calls Jesus Lord, except by the Holy Spirit. Matt 16:16-17 Jesus says to Peter, flesh and blood did not reveal this to you.

Psalm 51:17 A Contrite and broken heart and spirit God will not despise.

Abraham and Moses still had Free will? Or did they not have free will.
Why would you say they didn't?

If you read scripture with zero discernment and understanding you will read ''God told Abraham to sacrifice his son, or else''. God told Moses to lead His people out, or else.

Now, if you look at for example how Jesus chose the disciples you will see that thought was given to the selections. God is not an ''idiot''. He scours the earth for good people.

Abraham, Moses, David and all the OT prophets stood out in that they were all after God's heart.

Abraham interrogated God on the destruction of Sodom in Gen 18. Abraham saw God was good. Abraham did not blindly obey God's instruction to sacrifice his son. He knew that this insanely good God had a very good reason for asking something so extreme of Him.

David says, ''Guys, give thanks because God is good'' Psalm 136:1. He could be wicked per a read of Rom 9, but per the rest of scripture, He is not.

He is light with NO darkness in Him at all 1 John 1:5. We ''insert'' darkness. As we try grasp God of the universe with the peanut between our ears.
 
"If God was your neighbor, you would always be on your best behavior or want to run away to another part of the universe. "

Forgive me speaking out of turn.

I could think of hardly anything more entertaining than the prospect of having God as a neighbor. I doubt I would be on my "best" behavior. Why should I? He already knows all of the very worst I do. I would be on "good" behavior, as I am with all my neighbors. Still, I can't shake the feeling he'd very quickly find some excuse to move to another neighborhood. And I'll wager he'd be DEEPLY disappointed with the price he'd get for his house.
Your understanding of God is terrible.

God loves you more then anyone!!!. More then you love yourself. He made it possible for any of us to be with Him. Despite our sin and imperfections.

The decision to not be with Him is yours. We choose to move away because we reject the light. What is good and right.

The point I am making is that were we with God, we would have a similar scenario to that of the angels. It seems God did not want this with us. I think it has a lot to do with the fact that we are created beneath the angels. Angels seem able to stick to their hearts intents. Humans tend to be very hateful today and very loving tomorrow.
 
Hi Kirby, I hope you don't mind me taking a stab at your post to Samson.

1. I reject the very notion of human sacrifice, for any reason, on principle. If I had been at Calvary I would have seen it as my moral duty to thwart the Crucifixion, no matter who Jesus was. And I would consider failing to put a stop to it a great moral defeat on my part, one from which I doubt I could ever fully recover.

Every good person on the planet would agree with you.

You need to understand the necessity and a fuller context to the cross. We need to better grasp God's desire for a blood covenant with mankind / a creation.

God wanted this deeper connection with a creation. The crucifixion was not merely to save us from death, but also for His purpose in that He wanted this ''strong'' unbreakable bond with a creation.

God gave His life for us because He wants a life with us. There is no greater act of love then to lay your life down John 15:13. God wants us to know the depth of His love for us.
 
2. The principle of vicarious redemption is unjust and impracticable. I cannot blame another for anything Adam or Eve or anyone else ever did. No act of repentance or sacrifice on the part of any person can offset my own responsibility for any of my own wrongs. And (most especially) if in the unjust case that Jesus’s suffering can assuage the guilt of the sins of all mankind, then my own sacrifice ought to be worth SOMEthing. I don’t ask to save an entire generation, nor even just one nation of people. If I knew, for certain, sacrificing myself could in any way spare the suffering of my two children, I would offer myself up with a smile on my lips and a song in my heart. I think I would do it for some arbitrary number of perfect strangers, even. But I can’t. Can I?

You reasoning is sound. You are 100% correct and if you would truly offer your life for someone else, your heart is in the right place. You are after God's heart.

What many don't fully grasp is that scripture does not teach God is a nutter who would simply send all who do not choose option A over B, to an eternity in hell. Its more complex.

Adam's sin is not on us. We pay for our sins only Rom 2:6. We grow up in an environment of sin because he sinned. But also because God gave him a weak flesh that would inevitably sin and the devil with him in the garden. So, I am going to propose that us being one with sin, has always been an inevitability. If you and I were Adam, we would have done the same as him, perhaps even sinned sooner.

Hence, it needs to be clear that sin per sae is not ''the issue''. Repenting vs not repenting is. We see this as clear as daylight if we consider Hades in the OT. There was a separation of sinners in Hades. One half was in Abrahams bosom. If Jesus never died, all those who hate what is wicked and repent, would go there. IE Jesus cannot save anyone from hell. IE Jesus reconciles those who want to repent of their sins, with God.

Jesus washes us clean because we want to be washed clean. Nobody gets washed unless they too are truly after God's heart / able to lay their lives down for God as He did for them.

Example: Lets say you and I were in the army. Neither of us are perfect. We both have our faults. You defrauded me before the army and have a history of being short tempered. Then, in battle someone shoots at me. You jump in front and take the bullet. Sacrificing your life for mine. If you survive. You will be welcomed in my house for the rest of eternity. Despite your past and current issues. You have shown a depth of intent for me that covers everything else. It is exactly the same reason we are bonded with God and God is bonded with us.

True self sacrifice works both ways in Christianity. People don't become Christians because they say magical words. Matt 16:24 Then Jesus said to his disciples, “Whoever wants to be my disciple must deny themselves and take up their cross and follow me.

Matt 24:9 Then you will be handed over to be persecuted and put to death, and you will be hated by all nations because of me. Matt 24:13 but the one who stands firm to the end will be saved.
 
Last edited:
3. I once was convinced that morality, as taught in the Bible, was sophisticated, enlightened and infallibly just. The more I live, the more I become convinced it is quite an uninteresting instance of “carrot and stick” morality, based entirely upon imagined (and probably imaginary) rewards and punishments. These can be very effective inducements to moral behavior, but my children are not yet out of their teens and they both outgrew this very unsophisticated, transactional ethical code years ago.

Would you mind giving examples of carrot and stick morality.

I’m afraid I don’t find any bit of it very enticing. But, recall, nor do I find its reality convincing.

When you grasp the love God has for you, your life will change.

I am glad to see you are searching Kirby. It just pains me to know that another day in your life has passed where you could have been of service to God. One-day when you meet Him and grasp how good and loving He is, you will kick yourself!!!!!
 
You must consider that if God raised Jesus from the dead then what was it for God to have him die in the first place? The real feat was for the faith that Jesus had in his Father to actually raise him up, but since he had already raised up Lazarus even his faith had been strengthened. And you sound just like Peter who did not want Jesus to be taken and crucified and was rebuked by Jesus for not loving the things that be of God. Thats what we call SELF PRESERVATION, and self must die for the betterment of ALL.

The body of MAN is as grass. It is the spirit of man that God is concerned with, to mature it to the point he can trust it to do no harm. Indeed it is the fear of death that causes us to be sinners as we believe we only have 1 life and we need to make the most of it.
Your sacrifice will be worth something to God and you will gladly lay it down when he requires you to. "Precious in the sight of the Lord is the DEATH of ALL his saints." As to your not liking the way God did things its just simply a misunderstanding of Gods intentions for all and someday it will become clear that all suffering was worth the price for the reward attained. Jesus as an example has been appointed as the King of all creation in heaven and earth, angels included, and has attained to the level of a God (one who is spirit that cannot die and can give life to others).
Gods decision to conclude ALL men in unbelief so that he may have mercy upon ALL men offends you? God wanted to make salvation a gift so not one person could say I EARNED IT SO I'M BETTER THAN ANOTHER. Your own wrongs as you see them are evil in your eyes but what do you suppose God would say? That you had free will to do what you did or he made you so that you would fulfill whatever part he had ordained for you to fulfill as a man?
Forgiving oneself is easier when you know why you did what you did, help mature another. The real problem is the fact that you enjoyed it thats where your sacrifice will come to bear when your own selfish carnality is required to die in the face of the same evil you relished in comes directly at you and you must love it thou it kills you, knowing it is God that wields the blade.


Free gifts do not come with exceptions. But position within this spiritual kingdom does make requirements of you.
And who you call your kids are actually his as are you. You are the father of their flesh, but God is the Father of their spirit. "And without the spirit the body is dead."

If there is any 1 thing more important to understand than another bring it up and lets see where it goes.

I personally contribute my calling from a small book written by an evangelist from South America, can't say it was anything special but God saw it as the one piece I needed.
But you know the story...... GOD works in mysterious ways!!

Thank you, again, Samson 2020.

I think, if I had to articulate a single fundamental Christian principle to which I am most averse, I would call it “divine tyranny.”

I’ve tried to raise it here numerous times in numerous ways and, though the conversations they garner are usually interesting, they almost always veer off on tangent exploring the benefits believers derive in their belief.

One of these was the proposition, “What would you do if you learned you have been mistaken all along, that you are not a human with some eternal soul, but instead a mechanical android lacking any?” This was not done to you with any malice, and everybody else in your life thinks you are the genuine article. The simulation of your construction is so lifelike, and your own sense of identity is so real, even you cannot tell. Don’t ask me how you came to this conviction or how it’s even possible. Just accept, for the sake of argument, it is so.

For my part, there is not a thing I would change about how I live my life. However, if “real” people with “real” souls who worship God with sincere devotion get to go to Heaven, I would consider it completely unjust if I were not allowed to. This is not to say I wish I went to Heaven. I don’t and wouldn’t. But the situation strikes me as fundamentally and irredeemably unfair.

Likewise, whenever I attempt to draw any analogy between my supposed relationship with God and my relationship with my children, I run hard aground upon a “heads I win, tails you lose,” fallacy. I have been told that, as my children’s (small c) “creator,” I am entitled to expect their devotion and obedience. While at the same time, I am told I am NOT entitled to their spirit, THAT belongs to God –– precisely the argument of your previous remarks.

So, all my analogies seem inadequate. Another I am fond of is one in which I set up an ant farm. Let’s say I do that and go to extraordinary lengths to provide my ants with their every need: food, sunlight, opportunity to lead a productive and fulfilling ant life. It would just never OCCUR to me to expect or even accept their worship. I would never penalize them for so much as being imperfectly able to comprehend who or what I am. Not even if, on an ongoing basis, again and again, I interceded to prevent them hurting each other and themselves.

So here I am: A humble ant. And some other ants insist we are all the pets of an incomprehensibly huge and powerful being who alone is the source of everything I cherish, including (oddly) my own ant offspring. And that our cosmic PURPOSE is twofold: to be loved by it and to love it in return. Setting aside I see nothing compelling in any evidence these religious ants show me that the Great Being even exists, I wonder, assuming this is true, how the heck I got roped into this situation without either any knowledge or consent. The unfairness I sense is compounded when the religious ants also insist I have complete free will. And that its only appropriate use is the free “choice” to love and worship the Great Being.

That is precisely not the reason I had kids. I delight in my children. I glory in any affection they deign to show me. But that’s all just gravy, icing on the cake. The reason I had them was the joy I take in seeing them mature and thrive. Now, you may claim that is how God views my relationship with him, but by my lights it comes with an asterisk: So long as I give credit where credit is due. If he loves me any less in the absence of that, if he would allow me to suffer because of any deficiency on that score alone…

I’d be on the market for a different ant farmer.
 
I think, if I had to articulate a single fundamental Christian principle to which I am most averse, I would call it “divine tyranny.”

You've hit the nail on the head. It is divine Tyranny on Gods part. He is going to make of you and all of us sons of his that never existed before but did exist with him as a
part of him. Just as he took a rib from Adam to make his mate, in like fashion he took of himself to eventually have children that grow up to be just like him. We were with him
before the world was formed, Titus 1:2, and the promise of eternal life was made to us. We as part of God had eternal life to begin with but we were not like God we were more like a cell of an organ, just part of a whole. But the experience of life and the good and evil are necessary to be like God then once accomplished as he sees fit we are released
from being vessels of dishonor (doers of evil) and become vessels to honor and begin the process of salvation (growing up into him in all things) as he grows us. If you can see the whole process as a finished product you will see every human ever born as a son of God existing in a spiritual realm coexisting in love with him and of course Jesus our
elder brother. God wanted multitudes of children and he will have them, so DIVINE TYRANNY is a good phrase to describe the excellent plan. Now do you think that I would be a believer of free will? No! For what God has planned is far greater than I could imagine for myself so I concede to his wisdom. But I will say that if I were to drive from New York to LA the stops and rest areas I might choose to stop at could indeed be random but the starting point and the finishing point are pre-determined.
 
If you are good, you will hate what is wicked. If you hate what is wicked you will repent. If you repent truthfully OT or NT God will not reject you. In the NT, yes, God will reveal Jesus as Lord to you.

Is repenting separate from making amends?
Why would you say they didn't?

God revealed himself to Abraham and Moses in the Bible, and spoke to them directly. I think Abraham even had a conversation with God. I have not received the same as has many others. I have read some other Christians here say that God reveals himself only to a select few.
 
Is repenting separate from making amends?

Making amends is evidence of sincere repentance.

God revealed himself to Abraham and Moses in the Bible, and spoke to them directly. I think Abraham even had a conversation with God. I have not received the same as has many others. I have read some other Christians here say that God reveals himself only to a select few.

God is impartial Acts 10:34.

He had to go to the level of a burning bush and literal conversation in His dealings with certain chosen individuals to achieve His purposes. We need to grasp that if you or I were as good a person as Abraham at that time, we would have likely been chosen instead of him.

Jesus and the cross was planned before the foundations of the earth Eph 1:4. As such needing an Abraham, Isaac and all the prophets chosen were essential to Jesus coming when He did.

Once Jesus left earth after His resurrection, it was only Paul who had a literal encounter with God. Paul was used to write 3/4 of the NT. Him and the disciples all chosen to spread the good news of '''God wanting a deep and meaningful relationship with each of us''.

I know it may seem hard to believe, but Jesus / God does talk to us. Each one of His people know His voice John 10:27.

I will argue that today we can have live conversations with God whenever we choose. God does make His presence known to us via the Holy Spirit.

I do not believe God has a literal conversation with any outside of absolute necessity. As the bible is written and we are now living in the ''Revelations'' section, there is no need for Him to protect a Jewish race to usher in Jesus to the cross or explain how to live by faith as the disciples and Paul have already explained this. As such, If He did talk differently / literally to any of us, it could be argued to be partiality. He is righteous in ALL His ways Psalm 145:17 and impartial, so it is highly unlikely.

As I explained earlier, it is God's preference that He be ''removed'' as much as possible to allow for true free will to exist.

There is a lot more to understand too. If we look at David, we see that David was not always close to God. He committed mortal sins. Even though we are Christians, God still removes Himself from us to allow us to have free will. I don't believe this will change in heaven either. God is not overbearing and a tyrannical dictator. In heaven many will not want to talk to God or live next some annoying people. 99% of us have issues and are not as devout as the 1%. It is just the way it is. Can you or I endure what Job did for God? I think not. Must we now be jealous that God spoke a lot more to Job then He does to us? I think not. As Christians, we are able to talk to God as much as we want and have as close a relationship to Him as we want. But most, even though they are Christians, do still not want that. Hard to believe but 100% true.
 
Now do you think that I would be a believer of free will? No!

No free will is a mistaken assumption we make. We have a peanut between our ears and we assume we can grasp God of the universe just because we know the dictionary definition of the word ''omniscient''.

No, we can't. We need to grasp that God is as good as He is great. As such He be able to withdraw Himself to allow for true free will. Anything less then true free will is wicked, fact.

God is not wicked. He is light with no darkness in Him at all 1 John 1:5. He is a God who chooses to be righteous in ALL His ways Psalm 145:17. Just because God can be evil, does not mean He is. Just because God can know something, does not mean He does.

God imposes limitations on Himself in His dealings with us, fact. We see this with ''CRYSTAL'' clarity in how Jesus was a Lamb to the slaughter.

So, in essence, to propose there is no free will is a mockery of the cross. All the evidence points to it. Jesus truly died for the whomsoever John 3:16 For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life.
 
You've hit the nail on the head. It is divine Tyranny on Gods part. He is going to make of you and all of us sons of his that never existed before but did exist with him as a
part of him. Just as he took a rib from Adam to make his mate, in like fashion he took of himself to eventually have children that grow up to be just like him. We were with him
before the world was formed, Titus 1:2, and the promise of eternal life was made to us. We as part of God had eternal life to begin with but we were not like God we were more like a cell of an organ, just part of a whole. But the experience of life and the good and evil are necessary to be like God then once accomplished as he sees fit we are released
from being vessels of dishonor (doers of evil) and become vessels to honor and begin the process of salvation (growing up into him in all things) as he grows us. If you can see the whole process as a finished product you will see every human ever born as a son of God existing in a spiritual realm coexisting in love with him and of course Jesus our
elder brother. God wanted multitudes of children and he will have them, so DIVINE TYRANNY is a good phrase to describe the excellent plan. Now do you think that I would be a believer of free will? No! For what God has planned is far greater than I could imagine for myself so I concede to his wisdom. But I will say that if I were to drive from New York to LA the stops and rest areas I might choose to stop at could indeed be random but the starting point and the finishing point are pre-determined.

I must say, I have not come across many Christians who don’t believe in free will. I could ask if this doesn’t make you feel a bit like a wind up toy with absolutely zero autonomous agency in the course your life follows. (A feeling I would always seek to avoid.) But you raise a separate issue I am always curious about. You seem convinced your spirit shall live for all eternity. Can you describe why this is so and explain what you find desirable about the idea?
 
I must say, I have not come across many Christians who don’t believe in free will. I could ask if this doesn’t make you feel a bit like a wind up toy with absolutely zero autonomous agency in the course your life follows. (A feeling I would always seek to avoid.) But you raise a separate issue I am always curious about. You seem convinced your spirit shall live for all eternity. Can you describe why this is so and explain what you find desirable about the idea?

Actually it sets me free knowing that I have an outcome and that outcome is not death. My only anxiousness is not knowing when the next stage of maturing will come
but this is where patience comes to bear.
My spirit once joined unto the Lords Spirit have become One Spirit thus He lives forever and so do I. 1Co 6:17 "But he that is joined unto the Lord is one spirit."

I will give you a biblical example of free will not existing.

2 Tim 2:24-26 "And the servant of the Lord must not strive; but be gentle unto all men, apt to teach, patient, In meekness instructing those that oppose themselves; IF GOD PERADVENTURE WILL GIVE THEM REPENTANCE TO THE ACKNOWLEDGING OF THE TRUTH; And that they may RECOVER THEMSELVES OUT OF THE SNARE OF THE DEVIL, WHO ARE TAKEN CAPTIVE OF HIM AT HIS WILL."

Then ask one question of you. Are you here on this earth because of some choice YOU made or did God put you here?
 
No free will is a mistaken assumption we make. We have a peanut between our ears and we assume we can grasp God of the universe just because we know the dictionary definition of the word ''omniscient''.

No, we can't. We need to grasp that God is as good as He is great. As such He be able to withdraw Himself to allow for true free will. Anything less then true free will is wicked, fact.

God is not wicked. He is light with no darkness in Him at all 1 John 1:5. He is a God who chooses to be righteous in ALL His ways Psalm 145:17. Just because God can be evil, does not mean He is. Just because God can know something, does not mean He does.

God imposes limitations on Himself in His dealings with us, fact. We see this with ''CRYSTAL'' clarity in how Jesus was a Lamb to the slaughter.

So, in essence, to propose there is no free will is a mockery of the cross. All the evidence points to it. Jesus truly died for the whomsoever John 3:16 For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life.



I understand a desire to put God's best face forward in discussions such as this. But, despite the limitations of my primitive intellect, I CAN NOT overlook clear evidence in the Bible that, however superlative God's greatness is, it is rather lacking in the "goodness" department. It is too easy to cite horrors such as the genocide of Jericho, the Canaanites and the Amalekites, of allowing the sacrifice of Jepthah's daughter to teach Jepthah(!) a lesson, of the slaughter of Job's family to win a bet with Satan. And I've never come across any apologetic that in any way offers a satisfying "maximally good" interpretation of Isaiah 45:7 "I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil: I the LORD do all these things." One might CLAIM I'm reading it wrong, that since I don't believe I can't comprehend, when God says he is the source of evil, he means anything other than he is the source of evil. But no claim to any "correct" interpretation is any more valid than my own. If the Bible is God's word, I won't be expected to search for deeper meaning than that which reveals itself in my plain reading of the letter on the page. 1 John 1:5 may indeed assert God is all light and in him there is no darkness. But in Isiah God owns he is the source of evil. I can accept both assertions and admit, whether he's real or he isn't, he is a complicated, complex, somewhat inscrutable character with undeniable contradictions. But these contradictions ARE characteristically consistent; He says explicitly he made Man in his own image. Apart from occasional flashes of brilliance and a depressing penchant for sadism, the most distinguishing characteristic between humans and the rest of the animal kingdom is our confounding capacity for contradiction. For your part, you are not compelled to reconcile these ambiguities. However, you must if you are to wish they don't exist.

Forgive me if I seem over strident. I am willing to be convinced God exists. But I will go happily to Hell ––forEVER–– before i concede any genocide is anything other than evil. I don't think people should try to rehabilitate God's reputation on such matters. Judging by Isaiah 45:7, he doesn't seem to mind. Why do you suppose you should?
 
Actually it sets me free knowing that I have an outcome and that outcome is not death. My only anxiousness is not knowing when the next stage of maturing will come
but this is where patience comes to bear.
My spirit once joined unto the Lords Spirit have become One Spirit thus He lives forever and so do I. 1Co 6:17 "But he that is joined unto the Lord is one spirit."

I will give you a biblical example of free will not existing.

2 Tim 2:24-26 "And the servant of the Lord must not strive; but be gentle unto all men, apt to teach, patient, In meekness instructing those that oppose themselves; IF GOD PERADVENTURE WILL GIVE THEM REPENTANCE TO THE ACKNOWLEDGING OF THE TRUTH; And that they may RECOVER THEMSELVES OUT OF THE SNARE OF THE DEVIL, WHO ARE TAKEN CAPTIVE OF HIM AT HIS WILL."

Then ask one question of you. Are you here on this earth because of some choice YOU made or did God put you here?

You don't have to convince me Man's will is only as free as God is willing to allow. Hardening Pharaoh's heart against his inclination 9 times in a row is hardly standoffish.

But your question poses a false dichotomy. I do not know if I was brought into being for any intended purpose. I am here. I am more or less certain of that much. I've never felt any need for some specific, explicit "purpose" such as the one Christianity proposes. If there is one I would like to know about it, just as I am eager to know everything I can about my condition. I will say this: If it turns out Christianity is an accurate worldview, I will be very disappointed in it. And disappointed in God. To have made such implausible, inefficient contraptions as us who, despite all our flaws, are still capable of the most amazing wonders... to beget all that for the boring purpose of abasing ourselves in worship and devotion to a being who (if he is all he is cracked up to be) certainly doesn't need such adulation as a reason to get out of bed in the morning seems, honestly, very, very sad.

For a long time I wasn't sure I wanted to live forever. Not so long ago I suffered a medical catastrophe that brought me to the brink of death. It was long and arduous and I had a lot of time to ponder these things. What I came to was a conviction, while I'm in no hurry to die, I have no interest in life eternal. To illustrate, describe for me you notion of what life might be like after death and we'll see if I find it at all appealing. (Honest. Promise.)
 
I understand a desire to put God's best face forward in discussions such as this. But, despite the limitations of my primitive intellect, I CAN NOT overlook clear evidence in the Bible that, however superlative God's greatness is, it is rather lacking in the "goodness" department. It is too easy to cite horrors such as the genocide of Jericho, the Canaanites and the Amalekites,
God gave these wicked people ample time to repent. Their destruction was swift and overdue. They were wicked!

We see God's goodness in that He gave them time and did not repay evil with evil. He gave them a swift destruction. He always does. Sodom, flood. Swift.

of allowing the sacrifice of Jepthah's daughter to teach Jepthah(!) a lesson
We see He did this too with the tenth plague on Egyptians. It seems children are used as a means of God punishing disobedience. If we judge the A - Z of the scenario, we see a good God. Children die swiftly and are taken to heaven. Heaven belongs to those like them Luke 18:16.

of the slaughter of Job's family to win a bet with Satan.
You need to look deeper and grasp a truth about mankind on earth in the first place.

God is looking for a bride. God is looking for people after His heart. Those who truly hate what is wicked. Those like Mother Theresa. Those like Mother Theresa who '''KNOW'' God and place 100% faith in Him, despite what hits them.

Many persecutions hit Paul. Many persecutions hit every person close to God. God wants to see what we are made of. Much like you would like to know your wife would endure temptation and remain faithful to you. It will take you to deeper depths of love in your relationship.

All God did to Job was allow the devil to test him. The death of Job's family is a bit hard to discern. We know they were not as close to God as he was. He prayed for his children as he feared God not approving of their lifestyle. His wife told him to curse God.

Paul and Job will go to heaven and wear crowns for all eternity that read '''served God despite hell hitting them''. God loves Satan. God loves Job. God loves Job's wife. God loves Job's children. We are NOT in a position to fully grasp the A - Z of their time on earth or their eternal resting places. So, how can we properly judge God on the matter? What we do know is that Job was a good man after God's heart and he was tested and passed the test.

God has every right to test us and He will. It is for our eternal reward and a deeper relationship with Him. God ''CRAVES'' these deeper relationships with us. He made mankind for this!! LOVE, GENUINE LOVE!!!!!

Job would lay his life down for God. That is love. God is wicked for wanting this and bringing this out of Job? I think not.
 
Back
Top