without effort, how do we get grace? I mean, ultimately grace belongs to God and he can give it to whomever he wants for any reason he wants, but my reasoning tells me that the point of grace is to help us where we fall short, so that even though we are not perfect, we still have a shot at salvation. But if we don't even try, then then there is nothing to fall short of, and so grace seems unlikely.
mylittlepony -- you're spot on. Absolutely. Grace
is unlikely. Very unlikely. Scandalous, in fact.
You ask "without effort, how do we get grace"? We
don't get grace. That is to say, it is not something that can be
acquired, bought, or "gotten". Yes, we need to make a choice for its offer to become realized by us, this is true.
Surrendering? I guess I'm not sure of what part of that you are wanting further explanation on? I view it as a
relinquishing of our own will, and our own goals/wants/seeming-needs/plans/control, resulting in an
openness and humility and gratitude oriented towards Him. The kind of openness that hinges on our faith and trust in Him, based on belief in His goodness.
As for this idea of "doing things for Jesus"...I'm referring to the kind of "Christian'ized pride" that we so often witness in the Church (at large). You know, along with being a Christian, and living our lives in the entire
culture that has developed around that notion, it is viewed by our peers as "good / honorable / righteous" to kind of "do things for Christ". So, what I was referring to above, was relating to that notion of "doing things for Christ", when in fact, much of those things that are being done are either to make ourselves feel like we're doing ok (i.e., we've "checked the box", and given ourselves a star)...or doing it to gain the attention/respect of the Christian culture that floats around us.
So, again, this can be a nuance...because we may self-deceive because they are close first cousins to each other, but it is a world apart when we're actually living our lives in humbly obedience to our Maker, vs "doin' it for God" because we'll either feel better about ourselves or we'll get positive attention from the Christian-circuit. Hope that gives more clarity on what I was trying to say above.
As for desires --- if you really want to get into this, I highly recommend reading
The Journey of Desire by John Eldredge. It's a great book. But quickly: lets use your example of havin the desire to steal a soda pop. Is that inherently good or bad?
I don't believe the
desire is good, or bad. It just IS. What you
do with it, of course, can be life-giving, or life-sucking, and you can cause it to lead towards, or manifest as, sin. So, what drives this desire to steal the soda pop? That's what's important. What drives you. What causes this desire. Where does it eminate from? What are we
really wanting? What would that soda pop
really get for us? What would it really do for us? How would it make us feel, if we stole it? etc etc.
Again, the desire, in and of itself, is not something you chose, it's just something you felt. Do you view that as evil, or bad?
This thread is on porn. Is the desire -- or, perhaps we can call this
temptation -- to view porn inherently good, or bad?
If we call it
bad, and squelch it, toss it to the roadside, run it over, and drive away with our smiley feel-good faces, I suggest we miss something. Something big. Something helpful. Something useful. Something that God can use, as "text" to help us see what is really behind the "desire" or "feeling" we can identify with.
The desire isn't bad, or evil. What we do with it, and how we do or don't examine it, can lead towards death. Or life. (which goes full-circle back to your questions about how we "get" grace. Or, how I think about it: how we might find ourselves in the middle of grace)