Welcome!

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.

SignUp Now!
  • Welcome to Talk Jesus Christian Forums

    Celebrating 20 Years!

    A bible based, Jesus Christ centered community.

    Register Log In

Suicide

TheVermin: What really is your problem? I know what faith is. You are saved by having faith in Christ. Faith in his shed blood to be specific because without the shedding of blood there is no forgiveness of sins.

Repentance leads to salvation. Repentance is a condition of your heart as in sorrow for your sinful condition and understanding that you need a savior. An example being the story of the Pharisee and the Tax Collector. The religious Pharisee who was puffed up with pride was not justified but the humble tax collector who knew he was a sinner in need of grace and in humbleness of heart pleaded for mercy was. There is the difference hence God saying he resists the proud but gives grace to the humble.

The condition for entering heaven is faith in Christ which is much more than just simple belief but a total dependance on and trust in Christ to save you since you cannot save yourself. Christ is the one who saves you and keeps you. You have nothing to boast about. You can do good works as evidence of your salvation but they will not save you. You can confess all your sins to God and you will be made more and more into the image of Christ. This is a process and it is called sanctification. If you doubt then look at the church in Corinth and how immature they were as Christians yet they were still considered to be believer's. God will never forsake you or leave you but as a child he will discipline you just like an earthly parent does. Here is the difference. When you are saved you are sealed with the Holy Spirit. You have passed from death to life eternal though Christ. There is no condemnation for those in Christ Jesus. God's wrath only remains on the unsaved since they have not accepted Christ's payment for sin which was paid for in full on the cross. Christ did not make a partial payment. Christ said it is finished on the cross.

Those under grace are not law keepers. The law's purpose was to show what sin was. The law cannot save. I suggest you read Galatians. Those were the ones who wanted to go back under the law. Either you are under God's grace, which is unmerited favor, or you are not. Either you are trusting Christ 100 percent for your salvation or you are not. If you are trusting in yourself and your own works as in keeping the law perfectly then you are doomed and have forfeited grace. You have insulted Christ who suffered and paid the penalty on your behalf. You are striving instead of resting in Christ for your salvation.

If you choose to go back to the law then you nullify grace. The letter of the law kills but the spirit gives life. Grace means living by the spirit and not by legalistic religious requirements that only enslave and result in bondage to the law.

Then you might say does this grace give license to sin? Of course not. But one needs to be careful not to misinterpret and try to go back under the law when you were saved by God's grace and not your own works.

As for you quoting me? What's up with that? I know what depression is like and what it is like to contemplate suicide. And what I said was true and I'm not retracting it either.

God does not like hypocritical judgment. That's why we are told to examine ourselves first. Ultimately we can judge actions as right or wrong but only God can judge people's hearts since he is the only one privy to it's contents.

The reason I posted what I did is because a lot of damage can be done to people who are already depressed and hurting who happen to be believer's when they read the self-righteous comments of religious Pharisee types.

Thank you,
 
Chad that is a very heartless thing to say. You have obviously not been in the depths of despair because if you ever were you would never say such a thing.

I detected judgment mainly from that portion of your post, and as to the scripture i posted it may not have been the best way to quote my thoughts; but i was trying to get the point out that faith in Christ is the mainline but at the same time that grace we recieve is dependant upon trying our best to do what is right and confess and repent from sin. Also, there is a good chance Chad has gone through such despair and still has come to believe what he does. I did not mean to offend of course by quoting you though
 
Last edited:
Just to add to the way my post was probably interpreted, i should make clear that I do not think suicide is ever the answer. The way I think sometimes is a bit twisted and I apologize if what I said gave anyone the idea that suicide is the answer to anything
 
killing yourself is murder. self murder. you percieved it in your mind and carried it out. the pharsies would "plot" on how they would arrest or kill jesus. this plotting is what makes it murder. if you are dead how can you repent?

thinking that God wont send you to hell or that God is so sweet he just forgives anyway is liberal. If God was a liberal why did Jesus die on the cross? Where the spirit of God is there is liberty but in contrast where there are liberals there is communisim. God is about setting the captives FREE.

The standard of Holyness lifestyle is above each and every one of us.
 
that's what makes it a tragedy...
i agree though that *hell* is the best incentive for any one to NOT take their own lives.
 
Would you go to hell if you committed suicide?? Am not sure what the bible says about it but if your hurting that bad do you think God would send you to hell :s

Please be honest with me just tell me what you think

~Rick~

A sensitive topic Rick yet one that is barely addressed at all in the bible and seldom discussed by brethren. However the bible describes several instances of suicide and there is also the passage which says in effect "it would be better to put a yoke around your neck and throw yourself into the sea" etc. Isn't that God actually telling someone to commit suicide? What about a Christian soldier on the battlefield mortally wounded and choosing to take their own life rather than suffer any longer? Which doesn't mean that the soldier thinks God cannot fix the problem. Indeed, it could be an act of God's mercy giving the soldier permission to end their own life? Or if a cruel dictator had a Christian dropped off on top of a mountain with no chance of climbing down to safety; what then? So will God condemn the Christian if they leaped off the mountain to a quick death instead of staying there and slowly freezing to death? Perhaps just as God didn't make Jesus suffer any longer on the cross, doesn't mean God murdered his own son? Or a doctor is a murderer when they pull the plug on a vegetable patient? Because, unfortunately or fortunately, depending on which faith, people do die even though God could prevent All deaths if he wanted to.

So who's to say God does not condone suicide in certain circumstances and/or that God himself might force a disciple to take their own life rather than endure excruciating suffering or certain death anyway? And God does not fix all people as we know. Christians die every day from cancer, disease, accident and everything else like that. So who are we to judge that "You reject Jesus as Savior (obviously)" if you take your own life? So I'd guess it's neither clear nor obvious and that some Christians do commit suicide and they are still saved? We have no proof either way.

At the same time, I don't advocate suicide. That appears to be something only God knows about? The biggest argument against suicide is that many believers call it 'murdering one's self' and since murder is a sin; yada yada yada. But there is no divine proof either way on that argument neither. So Rick, perhaps the simple answer to your question is; if God has someone planned for hell and that "someone" commits suicide, then yes they go to hell. But only God knows whether or not certain saved Christians take their own lives? And it's refreshingly mature to see this forum at least has the courage to face this topic and I certainly do not claim to know the "answer" for sure either.
 
Will a person go to Hell if they commit suicide?

Interesting question. Let me rephrase.

Will a person go to Hell for doing one specific work?

Why do people go to hell is a much better question.

Who was the first person ever to commit suicide?

Was it not Adam? Who chose to eat the fruit of which he knew that he would die if he ate. Something moved him to do it. The bible doesn't say anything about his thoughts or feelings but his actions. Eve was deceived and didn't believe.

Did Samuel go to Hell? I know he didn't commit suicide but consider his statement to Saul about Saul's death.

Moreover the LORD will also deliver Israel with thee into the hand of the Philistines: and to morrow [shalt] thou and thy sons [be] with me:

Saul committed suicide and then went to be with Samuel.

So why do people go to Hell anyway?

But after thy hardness and impenitent heart treasurest up unto thyself wrath against the day of wrath and revelation of the righteous judgment of God; 6 Who will render to every man according to his deeds: 7 To them who by patient continuance in well doing seek for glory and honour and immortality, eternal life: 8 But unto them that are contentious, and do not obey the truth, but obey unrighteousness, indignation and wrath, 9 Tribulation and anguish, upon every soul of man that doeth evil, of the Jew first, and also of the Gentile; 10 But glory, honour, and peace, to every man that worketh good, to the Jew first, and also to the Gentile: 11 For there is no respect of persons with God.

Its all about works. Works condemn a person to Hell. Can't save em' just condemn em'.

Jesus gives eternal life to all them that obey him (Heb 5:9). Where did he say that you can't commit suicide?

Which one of sins three part category does suicide fall into? Lust of the eyes, lust of the flesh or the pride of life?

Was suicide the description given for the unpardonable sin?

If you do something that you know will end in your death isn't it suicide? Even if your laying down your life for your friends? You know your going to die. So does motive change everything? Self-centered versus other-centered? We consider it noble if you do it for another but ignoble if you do it to escape your pain.

Do you think Jesus cares more for the woman caught in adultery than he does for the suicide victim? She never asked him to forgive her but what did he say to her? Neither do I condemn thee. Or what about the man sick of the palsy who was let down from the rooftop? He never asked for forgiveness but was forgiven. Be careful what you say 'must' be done to be forgiven.

These are just some thoughts that came to mind while reading the thread. First and foremost we ought to support the weak. Those who are ready to perish need us more than anything. But at the same time, let us be careful not to bite and devour one another but rather edify in love.

I am officially way past my bed time, sweet dreams in Christ

Gary
 
Wise thoughts on the suicide subject Gary. I won't comment on where Samuel was and Saul was headed though : x.
 
killing yourself is murder. self murder. you percieved it in your mind and carried it out. the pharsies would "plot" on how they would arrest or kill jesus. this plotting is what makes it murder. if you are dead how can you repent?

thinking that God wont send you to hell or that God is so sweet he just forgives anyway is liberal. If God was a liberal why did Jesus die on the cross? Where the spirit of God is there is liberty but in contrast where there are liberals there is communisim. God is about setting the captives FREE.

The standard of Holyness lifestyle is above each and every one of us.

Believe what you want but man doesn't have a clue how God judges suicide and it's certainly not Your decision who goes to hell; thank God. :) And just by threatening a person with hell if they commit suicide, might make You an accomplice to murder if they go through with it? Read the examples in these threads. We have no idea if God and/or Satan brings about suicide for whatever reason. So try to talk about what you know; not what you wish you knew? Otherwise use question marks ?????? when you can't prove what you say. No offense. :)
 
non-specific

Will a person go to Hell if they commit suicide?

Interesting question. Let me rephrase.

Will a person go to Hell for doing one specific work?

Why do people go to hell is a much better question.

Who was the first person ever to commit suicide?

Was it not Adam? Who chose to eat the fruit of which he knew that he would die if he ate. Something moved him to do it. The bible doesn't say anything about his thoughts or feelings but his actions. Eve was deceived and didn't believe.

Did Samuel go to Hell? I know he didn't commit suicide but consider his statement to Saul about Saul's death.

Moreover the LORD will also deliver Israel with thee into the hand of the Philistines: and to morrow [shalt] thou and thy sons [be] with me:

Saul committed suicide and then went to be with Samuel.

So why do people go to Hell anyway?

But after thy hardness and impenitent heart treasurest up unto thyself wrath against the day of wrath and revelation of the righteous judgment of God; 6 Who will render to every man according to his deeds: 7 To them who by patient continuance in well doing seek for glory and honour and immortality, eternal life: 8 But unto them that are contentious, and do not obey the truth, but obey unrighteousness, indignation and wrath, 9 Tribulation and anguish, upon every soul of man that doeth evil, of the Jew first, and also of the Gentile; 10 But glory, honour, and peace, to every man that worketh good, to the Jew first, and also to the Gentile: 11 For there is no respect of persons with God.

Its all about works. Works condemn a person to Hell. Can't save em' just condemn em'.

Jesus gives eternal life to all them that obey him (Heb 5:9). Where did he say that you can't commit suicide?

Which one of sins three part category does suicide fall into? Lust of the eyes, lust of the flesh or the pride of life?

Was suicide the description given for the unpardonable sin?

If you do something that you know will end in your death isn't it suicide? Even if your laying down your life for your friends? You know your going to die. So does motive change everything? Self-centered versus other-centered? We consider it noble if you do it for another but ignoble if you do it to escape your pain.

Do you think Jesus cares more for the woman caught in adultery than he does for the suicide victim? She never asked him to forgive her but what did he say to her? Neither do I condemn thee. Or what about the man sick of the palsy who was let down from the rooftop? He never asked for forgiveness but was forgiven. Be careful what you say 'must' be done to be forgiven.

These are just some thoughts that came to mind while reading the thread. First and foremost we ought to support the weak. Those who are ready to perish need us more than anything. But at the same time, let us be careful not to bite and devour one another but rather edify in love.

I am officially way past my bed time, sweet dreams in Christ

Gary

Yep Gary, there's a lot more we don't know about suicide than we ever will know? Unforgiveable? Probably in some instances by God's grace but no one knows for sure? Look at all the examples I gave and there are hundreds more just like them. And many or all could be acceptable to or even initiated by God for all we know? Blasphemy of the Holy Spirit is the only "unforgiveable" sin I'm aware of and I don't even know what that is. Probably murder too, if you do it after repentance? Maybe it's when a believer walks away from the Holy spirit; sorry can't recall the passage but if you can be led away from or turn against the Holy Spirit, I presume "that" may be it? But does the devil make them blaspheme the Spirit or can a person do it on their own? But it also says there will be found no adulterers etc. in heaven too; so who knows for sure about those things either? :) No one knows what sins or continued sins are covered by God's grace. But we'll sure find out come Judgment Day.

Though interesting to ponder, I'm not concerned about all the "why" questions. Most Christians can't come to agreement on most biblical things in the first place. But rather than just go Do what Jesus did command us per Mark 16:15 to go “into all the world, and preach the gospel to every creature” and baptize and heal etc. with the gifts of the Holy Spirit, we sit around and ask "why". So if you haven't obeyed Mark 16:15 yet, then asking questions is perhaps just an excuse for not obeying Mark 16:15 yet? C'mon folks, how many Sundays do "you" have to be told the same things over and over before you finally obey and do it? Forgive me if that sounded harsh but what good are church buildings if they're only used for listening but not for doing what you listened to? ;) Blessings all,

Paul
 
Yep Gary, there's a lot more we don't know about suicide than we ever will know? Unforgiveable? Probably in some instances by God's grace but no one knows for sure? Look at all the examples I gave and there are hundreds more just like them. And many or all could be acceptable to or even initiated by God for all we know? Blasphemy of the Holy Spirit is the only "unforgiveable" sin I'm aware of and I don't even know what that is. Probably murder too, if you do it after repentance? Maybe it's when a believer walks away from the Holy spirit; sorry can't recall the passage but if you can be led away from or turn against the Holy Spirit, I presume "that" may be it? But does the devil make them blaspheme the Spirit or can a person do it on their own? But it also says there will be found no adulterers etc. in heaven too; so who knows for sure about those things either? :) No one knows what sins or continued sins are covered by God's grace. But we'll sure find out come Judgment Day.

Though interesting to ponder, I'm not concerned about all the "why" questions. Most Christians can't come to agreement on most biblical things in the first place. But rather than just go Do what Jesus did command us per Mark 16:15 to go “into all the world, and preach the gospel to every creature” and baptize and heal etc. with the gifts of the Holy Spirit, we sit around and ask "why". So if you haven't obeyed Mark 16:15 yet, then asking questions is perhaps just an excuse for not obeying Mark 16:15 yet? C'mon folks, how many Sundays do "you" have to be told the same things over and over before you finally obey and do it? Forgive me if that sounded harsh but what good are church buildings if they're only used for listening but not for doing what you listened to? ;) Blessings all,

Paul

Brother, it sounds to me like you are working to live and grow in the grace of God. Just a thought about the 'unforgivable sin' of blasphemy of the Holy Spirit. I have been taught, by the Spirit, that I am his vehicle to which he speaks to others. The word of God proceeds out of my mouth unto them. They in turn are cut to the heart by his words and react accordingly. I am nothing but the tool he uses to do his work. Just like he used Peter on Pentecost, and Stephen before his stoning. Those that blaspheme his work in me are committing the unforgivable sin.

If you too possess the Holy Spirit and he is speaking through you then the same is true in you. It is as Peter and Paul spoke about. One says if any man speak let it be as the oracles of God and the other asks the question did the word of God come out from you only?

Let us continue to study to show ourselves approved, good work brother,

Gary
 
Brother, it sounds to me like you are working to live and grow in the grace of God. Just a thought about the 'unforgivable sin' of blasphemy of the Holy Spirit. I have been taught, by the Spirit, that I am his vehicle to which he speaks to others. The word of God proceeds out of my mouth unto them. They in turn are cut to the heart by his words and react accordingly. I am nothing but the tool he uses to do his work. Just like he used Peter on Pentecost, and Stephen before his stoning. Those that blaspheme his work in me are committing the unforgivable sin.

If you too possess the Holy Spirit and he is speaking through you then the same is true in you. It is as Peter and Paul spoke about. One says if any man speak let it be as the oracles of God and the other asks the question did the word of God come out from you only?

Let us continue to study to show ourselves approved, good work brother,

Gary

Hard to find His like-mindedness especially on the Internet brother. Indeed, cyberspace may very well be one of Satan's most diabolical deceptions ever? ;) Which is tantamount to pointing out the obvious to the oblivious but I think you have a reasonably good grasp of it. Blessings,
 
Back
Top