Dear Brother Dave,
The Scriptures are full of analogies, parables that describe the Word of God as this or doing that. Clearly the Word of God is not dirt, and we are not seeds. The important part was what was Brother Bill attempting to say by this example? That is what is important! Or do you really think that he was actually trying to say that the Word of God "is actually dirt" and we are "actually seeds" and not using it as an example that points us to enriching ourselves and growing by taking in God's Word?
How many preachers from the pulpit use their own analogies, even stories to make a point that is descriptive of the Word of God they are going over, in their lives, or the lives of others? Now put the Word of God into another language, and sometimes you'd be surprised where that gets you! lol I know because my first language is Spanish (Home), and English from the School/streets.
That is why translations can be tricky at times. Clearly you understood what he was trying to say, but instead of focusing on that you choose to focus on the actual words themselves as if he was intending to denigrate or misapply God's Word! Do you really think that is what he was trying to do? I do not.
Jesus answered and said to them, "Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up." John 2:19 NKJV
Without the Word of God, would we be any different in not understanding what our Lord & Savior Jesus was saying! So, you did good in testing him out, but the questioning you used needs a little work.
Now, if the association/context of what he wrote was out of Wack, I'd be right with you in correcting him Brother Dave! Or if he was actually saying that the parable you gave as support for his distortion was wrong, and his was right; then I'd be shoulder to shoulder with you in admonishing him!!!
I hope Brother Dave you get where I'm coming from in this.
@Bill Personally, I am more interested in what he is saying as it pertains to receiving the Holy Spirit. Is Brother Bill by his analogy talking about growing in the Word is necessary before one is indwelled by/with the Holy Spirit and if so, how does one get the understanding if the initial sealing of the Holy Spirit is insufficient to be guided or given understanding by or is it?
With the love of Christ Jesus.
YBIC
Nick
\o/
<><