To lecoop,
Yes I agree the 7<sup>th</sup> trumpet judgment and 3<sup>rd</sup> woe last for the 3.5 years of the great tribulation.
Sorry, I thought you would understand I meant the 7<sup>th</sup> trumpet judgment when said 7<sup>th</sup> trumpet. The trumpets start events as signals and the blast is short not for 3.5 years as you thought I believed.
Ah! It is the judgment!! NOW we are on the same page!
Revelation chapter 11 over laps or happens at the same time as all of the seal judgments, Thunder judgments, and the first 6 trumpet judgments.
Now we are in trouble again!:shock: How on earth can you say that?
John is EXTREMELY careful in his chronology! Please, lay this out for me verse by verse, as to why you believe this.
Here is how I think of it: Suppose you go to a play, suppose the nutcracker. It is long. They have an intermission in the middle for refreshments and bathroom calls. They also have two "acts" in the first half and two in the second half, where they close the curtain to rearrange the set.
This is what John does between the 6th and 7th seal: He drops the main, real-time theme of 7 seals - 7 trumpets - 7 vials, and drops into an "intermission" to rearrange the set. There are two events that absolutely MUST take place before john can get back to the real-time of the seals-trumpets-vials, to show the 7th seal that begins the Day of the Lord and the 70th week.
The 144,000 MUST BE sealed for their protection before the trumpet judgments come. Then, the rapture must take place, so we are not here for any part of God's wrath. (The trumpets are certainly a part of His wrath.)
So we find John's first "intermission" between the 6th and 7th seals.
John goes into a second and much longer intermission at the 6th trumpet. Again, he must rearrange the set! Things MUST take place before the 7th trumpet is sounded in heaven and the abomination takes place on earth. This "Midpoint Intermission" starts with chapter 10, and continues through chapter 15. It is long.
Now, back to the nutcracker. Suppose the curtain closes for the refreshments, and you get up to get to the restroom. But you are at the wrong end of an row of chairs and cannot move for a while. When you are just about to enter the aisle, suddenly the curtain opens, you see king soldier kill king rat, and the curtain closes as quickly as it opened. It all took only a few seconds! Most of the people MISSED IT entirely! Of course that would not happen, but that is exactly what John does.
He is IN an intermission, rearranging the set. But suddenly he opens the curtain for a real-time event (seals - trumpets - vials). He writes that the first and second woes are over and the third comes quickly and he writes the sounding of the 7th trumpet - two real-time verses written in an intermission!! But then the curtain is closed for rearranging the set, and will stay closed until the vials are mentioned in chapter 15.
(I thought "intermissions" were a good way to describe the difference between chapter 9 and chapter 10, for example.)
So get the picture of chapter 11: the 6th trumpet has been the last real-time event. (clocks still keep time even during an intermission - but none of the real-time of the play is missed). John is getting ready for the 7th trumpet, but the set MUST BE rearranged. The abomination will take place on earth at the same moment the 7th trumpet is sounding in heaven. So one part of the "set" that must be arranged: the BEAST MUST GET TO JERUSALEM!!
Therefore, please show us how you arrive at this conclusion of an overlap?
Think of Revelation as scenes in a movie, some happen on earth, some scenes are in heaven.
HA! Very much like I just described! Our minds seem to be running in along the same lines!! :shade:
I wish you and I could sit down with our Bibles and talk about the Bible in person. It would be great fun. Posting is hard for me. It is worth the effort to help all who read the post.
Agreed! There are many readers. I post mostly for them.
Chapters in the first half of the tribulation are as follows: 6 through 11:14, 12:6, 13, 14, 15, 17, 18
How I wished I had a rolling on the floor smiley! Eric, how on earth do you come up with this? Did you not see my previous post where I wrote this?
AXIOM on Revelation:
ANY theory that must rearrange John's God-given chronology is immediately suspect and WILL be proven wrong!
Sorry, Eric, but this is simply not the way John wrote! The exact midpoint is the 7th trumpet. Almost everything written in chapters 1-11 up to the 7th trumpet is BEFORE the midpoint. Almost everything written AFTER the 7th trumpet is AFTER the midpoint.
(I gave myself a tiny room for an exception. I know 12:1-5 is written as a parenthesis and is one exception.)
You say chapter 13? I think it is in the PERFECT place. Please understand, if two things happen at the same exact time, John cannot write one event on top of another! He is limited in that way. It is my belief that the man of sin will be be REVEALED as the BEAST until the midpoint. John is AT the midpoint in chapter 13. The events there, as proven by the 42 months, start at the midpoint.
Please show us any proof texts you can to support this belief?
History 12:1-5
Chapters in the last half of the tribulation are as follows: 11:15-19, 12:7-17, 16, 19, 20
What about 12:6 for example? I believe they begin to flee within seconds of seeing the abomination. So it would be AFTER. Why not include it? MOST of chapter 13 is what the Beast will be doing during those days of GT. They are OF COURSE in the last half.
Therefore your answer puzzles me. Why not leave John's chronology as is? It makes perfect sense as written. If you disagree, pinpoint a verse and we will discuss it.
Revelation 11:1-2 happen in the first half of the tribulation after the temple is built but before the middle of the tribulation. The antichrist will go into the temple and declare that he is god after he has control of the rest of the world. The abomination of desolation will be set up in the temple 30 days before the last half of the tribulation begins Daniel 12:11.
I disagree. You are working backwards with that 30 days. That was NEVER God's intent. You cannot possibly divide the week into two equal halves by the abomination if it is NOT in the middle. Why would you put more weight on the extra 30 days that you would no the word "midst?" BOTH are the words of God to us. If you leave MIDST as written and believe it, then the abomination divides the week into two EQUAL halves. And there is a perfectly good explanation for the extra 30 days AT THE END OF THE 3 1/2 YEARS. As it is, your theory DESTROYS the meaning of "midst."
Revelation 11:3-14 happens during the 1260 days of the fist half of the tribulation. When God causes the 10 kings to destroy Harlot Babylon and give their power to the antichrist Revelation 17:16-18, the antichrist will kill the two prophets and take control of Jerusalem. Jesus will come down to split the Mount of Olives to make a way of escape for the Jews Zechariah 14:1-5a
Why do you keep insisting on this, since it is impossible! John did not write as a jigsaw puzzle all jumbled up!
PLEASE follow this logic:
11:2 The Beast must get to Jerusalem so he can enter the temple: right? How could he do it if he was living in Syria?
But IN THIS VERSE is the 42 months he will trample.
Now you have a choice: does the city get trampled during the first half of last half?
If you say last half, you are correct, but then you have a HUGE Problem. Since it will be 42 months to the end, HE CANNOT possibly arrive in Jerusalem Three or four months before the abomination. If so, the trampling would be LONGER than 42 months.
NO, The timing of 11:2 MUST be shorter than 15 days (think rounding) before the abomination. I just guess a week or so. Could be 4 days. Cannot possibly be the day before. Why? The two witnesses.
What then is verse 3 about? Whatever it is about MUST COME in chronology AFTER the Beast arrives. But we don't even need to guess here.
We KNOW verse two must be limited to between 15 days and 3 1/2 days before the abomination. Therefore, since verse 3 follows verse 2, the two witnesses must show up AFTER the Beast. John would just NOT write it in reverse of the way it will happen!
The two witnesses MUST testify in the FUTURE of this verse 3, not in the PAST of verse 3, as you say. Why? John uses REAL FUTURE TENSE verbs: "they shall prophesy." It is very simple, John could not possibly use a future tense verb for a past action. Please note, MUST of John's verbs are Aorist tense, not inflected to show any timing whatsoever. Also, since there is NO MENTION of them before this, we can be ASSURED that they SHOW UP at the first verse of mention.
Since we KNOW they must testify for 1260 days, STARTING just before the midpoint, and testify all the way to chapter 16, near the end, then what is John's timing in verse 3? It MUST BE 3 1/2 days before the exact midpoint. The earthquake at their resurrection is the VERY SAME earthquake at the 7th vial that ENDS the week.
See how perfect is John's chronology? Therefore, 12:3 is EXACTLY 3 1/2 days before the 7th trumpet that divides the week.
"When God causes the 10 kings to destroy Harlot Babylon"
What can I say? This theory is MILES off base. Do you not understand WHO this Mystery Babylon is? Do you not understand WHY chapters 17 and 18 are there instead of earlier where you wish them to be?
If you erase your slate and start over using my axiom above, you will be miles ahead! Did you not read the last verse of chapter 17? John TELLS US who he means by Mystery Babylon!
The Great Wh*re Babylon is "that great city." Again, John TELLS us in a previous chapter what city. It is the city where Jesus was crucified.
Do you not understand that the GREATEST deception ever to come upon a people will come from the city of Jerusalem while the Beast makes his home there? He will claim to be "Jesus Christ," the Messiah to come! He will have MIRACLES to prove it, and will deceive the ENTIRE WORLD, save those that have their names written in heaven. NO WONDER God calls His beloved city "the great Wh*re Babylon.
Now can you see why chapters 17 and 18 follow chapter 16? Did you not read how these 10 kings give their power to the Beast for ONE HOUR? It is the LAST hour, when Jerusalem is destroyed, and burned, then also destroyed with the mighty earthquake, when the Old Testament saints arise at the 7th vial. Chapters 17 and 18 give us a close up view of her destruction. Eric, I am amazed you have not seen this.
No wonder you find the need to rearrange John's great book! It is because of your thinking! PLEASE, change your thinking! Don't rearrange the book!
Coop