Welcome!

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.

SignUp Now!
  • Welcome to Talk Jesus Christian Forums

    Celebrating 20 Years!

    A bible based, Jesus Christ centered community.

    Register Log In

The war within

I made no mention of "others".
You wrote..."I do not believer that God instantaneously makes every part of the Body flawless and ready to work perfectly in that Body... although He may do so with some."
So you actually DO believe He "instantaneously makes parts of the body flawless and ready to work perfectly in that body".
I believe that He can, but I also believe that He will not force anyone to work against their own will. Having our will perfectly equal to God's will is where we should ultimately should be. How many have been there immediately when they first received and answered His call? I won't tempt God by assuming I know the answer to the question.

The "flawless" portion of the equation comes from our rebirth from God's incorruptible seed.
The flawless will grow in grace and knowledge to ever enhance their usefulness to the Lord.
But they start out flawless.
A true repentance from sin will keep them flawless.
I do not entirely agree. What I see is an opportunity to do it right, but in this opportunity, I believe, we can fail even as Adam and Eve failed at their opportunity. The choice is ours. Before Jesus reopened the closed door there was no Way to enter in. Now there is a Way, but failure is also possible. How much do we love Him?
 
Hmmm... kind of takes Calvinism to a new level
I never saw any need to study Calvinism.

Whenever you ask someone who believes in OSAS, what about this person doing (homosexuality, adultery, fornication, etc...)
They will say... oh that person was never saved in the first place.
As salvation won't be assured till after the final judgement, our comments on its having been awarded already are moot.

You are raising the bar here and saying if they (lie, cheat, lust, dishonor parents, steal, etc...) any sin at all, they were never saved in the first place.
We serve who we love.
Servants of sin love sin more than they love God.

If that's the case, I'm not saved. I want to be, I try to be. You say "just stop sinning". You think I haven't tried? You think I don't want to?
You say "we can do all things through Christ who strengthens us". I believe that also.... but I haven't completely stopped sinning 100%
if I am honest with myself.
What does that say about your 'claim' of "wanting to"?
Don't waste another day of your life "wanting" something that is free for the taking.
Make up your mind right now that you will never sin again...and follow through with the desire.

I suspect under your rules, you might be the only Christian on TJ. @Christ4Ever, [USER]Fragrant Grace [/USER], @Chad, [USER]Br Bear[/USER]... none of them
are Christians according to you. @Dave M, @Bendito, @KingJ @Curtis -- none of us are Christians according to you.
If they don't line up with the words of Christ, their salvation will be in danger.

I myself have told people they aren't really Christians, when this happened, they didn't have scripture to support their beliefs.
You have been given dozens of scriptures of why we believe what we believe.
And I have replied in kind.
If my scriptures defend obedience to God and your's defend disobedience to God...which interpretation do you think is FROM God?

Now some of us have been Christians a long time. (even if you don't agree) and we take your teachings with "a grain of salt" so to speak.
We rather believe the majority of the Bible, rather than one verse. But new Christians who read this, will likely get discouraged and give up.
Give up what?
Belief that God can do all things that strengthen us? (Phil 4:13)
Belief that God will protect us from temptations that are too much for us? (1 Cor 10:13)
Belief that God's seed cannot bear evil fruit? (1 John 3:8-10)
Belief that "in Christ" we have every advantage Jesus had while on earth?
If these are NOT the things new believers want, they are not looking to serve God in the first place.

Lam 3:22; The Lord’s lovingkindnesses indeed never cease,
For His compassions never fail.
Lam 3:23; They are new every morning;
Great is Your faithfulness.
Prov 24:16; For a righteous man falls seven times, and rises again,
But the wicked stumble in time of calamity.
Micah 7:18; Who is a God like You, who pardons iniquity and passes over the transgression of the remnant of His inheritance—who does not retain His anger forever, because He delights in loving devotion?
Great OT scriptures, addressed to OT men.
Men who were not given the gifts of repentance, baptism in the blood of Christ for the remission of past sins, AND for the killing of the old man prior to rebirth from incorruptible, Godly seed.
Nor were they promised the gift of the Holy Ghost for a true turn from sin.
They were never promised or given the Comforter.
They walked in the flesh, while we can walk in the Spirit.

What they did have, however, were the foreshadowings of the NT.
Circumcision:...now the casting away of the flesh at baptism into Christ and into His death.
Dietary laws:...now the separation from that which is unclean.
Separation from the infidels in marriage:...now the separation of the holy from the unholy.
The Sabbath, now every day to those who love God above all else and have committed everything to God's hands.

Jesus said..."If ye love me, keep my commandments." (John 14:15)
Do you love Jesus?
 
I believe that He can, but I also believe that He will not force anyone to work against their own will. Having our will perfectly equal to God's will is where we should ultimately should be. How many have been there immediately when they first received and answered His call? I won't tempt God by assuming I know the answer to the question.
What is God's will?
Our salvation.
Isn't that the will/hope of new believers?
Why won't folks work toward their own salvation?
(This is a whole new thread, but the answer is because the devil has given them 400(?) false churches that have doctrines that cater to the unfaithful.)


I do not entirely agree. What I see is an opportunity to do it right, but in this opportunity, I believe, we can fail even as Adam and Eve failed at their opportunity. The choice is ours. Before Jesus reopened the closed door there was no Way to enter in. Now there is a Way, but failure is also possible. How much do we love Him?
You can fail, if the choice is to do so.
Or you can succeed, if that is your choice.
 
They walked in the flesh, while we can walk in the Spirit.

They did not all walk in the flesh. David repenting was walking in the flesh?

Putting the flesh to death by the spirit has been God's will from day 1 in the garden.

Why do you say you walk in the spirit when you teach over and over that you walk in the flesh? A perfect flesh.
 
Hmmm... kind of takes Calvinism to a new level :)

I don't know what denomination his belief falls into.

It is an off-shoot of Arminianism. Arminianism encompasses OSAS and non OSAS. He would be on the extremity of a non OSAS. A disagreement on 'the perseverance of the saints' in TULIP.

It is very good to be extra aware of self judgment. But I think you hit the nail on the head where you said ''discourages' new believers. It is almost as bad as teaching hyper grace / the extremity of an OSAS belief.
 
You can fail, if the choice is to do so.
Or you can succeed, if that is your choice.

only if you first repent.... only if you first believe.... only if you first hear..... only if one first preaches.... only if one is first sent.... by those who have done the above, according to God's own will and good pleasure, to His glory and praise.
 
could be a follower? Or maybe even one who believes in all that the Lord has shown him in His Word?


Bless you ....><>

so you saying you think the word showed him something different then the rest of us?? he is clearly wrong about his belief of all people will be instantly changed and yet you fail to address that I wonder why?? so you think allowing someone to have a completely wrong belief is Loving?

this is not something that is open for interpretation this is rock solid foundation 101 Christianity here and you my dear brother encourage this false doctrine I just dont know why. That is not a Loving thing to do at all. Correct and move on dont be rude but why would you encourage that type of thing is what I wonder.

I think your heart is getting the way of your judgement but I am not sure because I know you to be a loving kind caring person so that is the only thing it could be IMO

I admire @peice love for God and as brothers and sister of Christ when one of us is so far off in his understanding we should try to unite and shed some light of this dangerous false belief that could seriously harm new comers to the faith.

Just in case your not 100% sure what I am speaking about
I asked him
are you saying everyone that is Gods children is made perfect sinless instantly?

and if that does not happen they are not Gods children?

is this what you are saying?

Peice said
That is precisely what I'm saying.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Love to all under the Grace and Mercy of God
 
Greetings Dave,

thank you for your concern regarding me.

I began writing a reply to you, Dave.... after it got to about five feet long i took a break and asked the Lord to edit me.
I then wrote another reply that was only two and half feet long... and again, Lord, edit me, please....

so, several hours later....
the short answer is, what does the Bible say?
If I may add, what does the devil usually say (same as he did in the beginning)
and, what does the Spirit say?


Bless you ....><>
 
Last edited:
the short answer is, what does the Bible say?
If I may add, what does the devil usually say (same as he did in the beginning)
and, what does the Spirit say?

I wonder if some of us have gotten as comfortable listening to all three.
Maybe sometimes we should get up and turn the radio off.
 
They did not all walk in the flesh. David repenting was walking in the flesh?
It is written..."This I say then, Walk in the Spirit and ye shall not fulfil the lust of the flesh." (Gal5:16)
If he was walking in the Spirit, he wouldn't have fulfilled the lust of the flesh.
As David wasn't accorded the honor of baptism into Christ and into His death, burial, and wasn't raised with Christ to walk in newness of life, he walked in the flesh till his death.
Fortunately for him, he did have the atonements for sin listed in the Mosaic Law, or he would have been doomed.

Putting the flesh to death by the spirit has been God's will from day 1 in the garden.
You will need to provide a verse that says the flesh is put t death by the Spirit.
Especially when it is written in Romans 6 that our old man is killed at our "immersion" into Christ's death. (Rom 6:3-6)
Verse 7 tells us the outcome of the first 6 verses..."For he that is dead is freed from sin."
Thanks be to God!

Why do you say you walk in the spirit when you teach over and over that you walk in the flesh? A perfect flesh.
You are mistakenly equating the word "skin" for the word "flesh".
"Skin" refers to the vessel into which God's Spirit has been poured after our "turn from" sin.
God uses it to manifest His grace and glory on earth now.
"Flesh" refers to the wicked mind we have left behind at our conversion.

It is written..."And they that are Christ's have crucified the flesh with the affections and lusts.
If we live in the Spirit, let us also walk in the Spirit." (Gal 5:24-25)
The "skin" cannot cause or allow us to commit sin, but the "fleshly" mind will do both.
 
only if you first repent.... only if you first believe.... only if you first hear..... only if one first preaches.... only if one is first sent.... by those who have done the above, according to God's own will and good pleasure, to His glory and praise.
Amen.
As is frequently written here, "God knows men's hearts", to which I add a hearty AMEN, and He will cause the "preaching" to be heard by those who are drawn to Him.
 
Greetings Dave,

thank you for your concern regarding me.

I began writing a reply to you, Dave.... after it got to about five feet long i took a break and asked the Lord to edit me.
I then wrote another reply that was only two and half feet long... and again, Lord, edit me, please....

so, several hours later....
the short answer is, what does the Bible say?
If I may add, what does the devil usually say (same as he did in the beginning)
and, what does the Spirit say?


Bless you ....><>

Brother Bear thank you for the short reply it is much appreciated !! I hope you are doing well today my dear freind and please do not let this trouble you. I will gladly answer your question but maybe it would be better if we start from what the bible does NOT say since that is what is the heart of the issue here.

So shall we take on the that first
---Gods children is made perfect sinless instantly?

So Bear do you believe this to be the case??

we dont all have to agree on everything, I do think we should agree on some basic 101 Christianity. But I am no scholar but to deny the fact that Christians mature and during that maturing process sometimes stumble in sin is simply not true. You seem to act like its a mean thing to speak up for the truth sometime. I do agree with you Bear when we speak to one another is should be done in the most respectful and loving way possible. I hope I have done that.
 
I don't know what denomination his belief falls into.
You could ask.
But to save you the time, there are no denominations in the body of Christ.
We here use the title..."The Church by Christ Jesus (Eph 3:21)".
If I were to use the term "denomination", I would have to say we were the "Arizona denomination".
Basically, a location denominator.
 
so you saying you think the word showed him something different then the rest of us?? he is clearly wrong about his belief of all people will be instantly changed and yet you fail to address that I wonder why?? so you think allowing someone to have a completely wrong belief is Loving?

this is not something that is open for interpretation this is rock solid foundation 101 Christianity here and you my dear brother encourage this false doctrine I just dont know why. That is not a Loving thing to do at all. Correct and move on dont be rude but why would you encourage that type of thing is what I wonder.

I think your heart is getting the way of your judgement but I am not sure because I know you to be a loving kind caring person so that is the only thing it could be IMO

I admire @peice love for God and as brothers and sister of Christ when one of us is so far off in his understanding we should try to unite and shed some light of this dangerous false belief that could seriously harm new comers to the faith.

Just in case your not 100% sure what I am speaking about
I asked him
are you saying everyone that is Gods children is made perfect sinless instantly?

and if that does not happen they are not Gods children?

is this what you are saying?

Peice said
That is precisely what I'm saying.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Love to all under the Grace and Mercy of God
Hi Dave,
Do you believe that the fruit of a fig tree can be a grape?
No?
Why then do you believe the children of God's seed can bring forth lies or murder?

What does "rebirth" entail, to you?
 
Rom 8:13; For if ye live after the flesh, ye shall die: but if ye through the Spirit do mortify the deeds of the body, ye shall live.

It doesn't say "kill"

mor·ti·fy
ˈmôrdəˌfī/Submit
verb
verb: mortify; 3rd person present: mortifies; past tense: mortified; past participle: mortified; gerund or present participle: mortifying
1.
cause (someone) to feel embarrassed, ashamed, or humiliated.
"she was mortified to see her wrinkles in the mirror"
synonyms: embarrass, humiliate, chagrin, discomfit, shame, abash, horrify, appall
"I'd be mortified if my friends found out"
2.
subdue (the body or its needs and desires) by self-denial or discipline.
"return to heaven by mortifying the flesh"
synonyms: subdue, suppress, subjugate, control; More
3.
archaic
(of flesh) be affected by gangrene or necrosis.
"the cut in Henry's arm had mortified"

A more accurate translation is...

Rom 8:13; for if you are living according to the flesh, you must die; but if by the Spirit you are putting to death the deeds of the body, you will live.

What does God say about David?

Acts 13:22; After He had removed him, He raised up David to be their king, concerning whom He also testified and said, ‘I have found David the son of Jesse, a man after My heart, who will do all My will.

I wonder how many of us will have an epitath given that we are Men after God's own heart.?
 
Do you believe that the fruit of a fig tree can be a grape?
No?
Why then do you believe the children of God's seed can bring forth lies or murder?

What does "rebirth" entail, to you?

Rebirth implies growing. Baby are birthed (born) and then they grow.

1 Cor 3:1; And I, brethren, could not speak to you as to spiritual men, but as to men of flesh, as to infants in Christ

Why then do you believe the children of God's seed can bring forth lies or murder?

Because the Bible say they aren't perfect yet. Even those these infants "in Christ" were in Christ... they were still fleshly.

The very next verses after stating they are "in Christ" says...

1 Cor 3:2; I gave you milk to drink, not solid food; for you were not yet able to receive it. Indeed, even now you are not yet able,
1 Cor 3:3; for you are still fleshly. For since there is jealousy and strife among you, are you not fleshly, and are you not walking like mere men?

According to this they can be fleshly and in Christ both at the same time.
 
Hi Dave,
Do you believe that the fruit of a fig tree can be a grape?
No?
Why then do you believe the children of God's seed can bring forth lies or murder?

What does "rebirth" entail, to you?
Hi @At Peace

I hope you are having a wonderful day. thanks for you response.

bible says those practicing sin will not inherit the kingdom of God. I think we agree on that !!

there is a difference between practicing sin and stumbling in sin. It is very clear in the bible that those who practice sin will not inherit the kingdom of God.

But we do have a advocate for us when we make a mistake and stumble in sin, this is the part that you seem so stern to ignore. I wonder why ?
 
What is God's will?
Our salvation.
When born to our natural mothers we had our own will which corresponded to where we wanted to be. The naturally born child is very selfish, but this not evil because that child only knows how to communicate discomfort: hunger, thirst, cold, hot, etc. In other words it is simply a self-preservation thing. Want really equals need, at least as the flesh understands need.

As the child grows and learns, including the ability to converse more clearly a line is drawn between want and need, but the child cannot see it. Good parents will teach the child the difference.
Isn't that the will/hope of new believers?
New believers are simply hungry and thirsty spiritually even as the new born baby in the flesh was simply hungry and thirsty physically. The infant did not understand it, but when mama fed him, he began to learn.

Similarly spiritually, a new born baby in the Lord [with little regard for physical age although it can matter] also does not understand, but when he is fed righteousness [Matt 5:6] he begins to learn.

As the child matures the selfishness should be moving toward the selflessness that Jesus manifested perfectly.

Why won't folks work toward their own salvation?
(This is a whole new thread, but the answer is because the devil has given them 400(?) false churches that have doctrines that cater to the unfaithful.)

People won't when they won't because they like it in the best of both worlds if they are able to get it. The problem with that choice is they may find themselves lukewarm and spit out of God's mouth. If they did not have one of the 400 (?) you mention they would have something else. There is always something else which we are able to choose besides God and His righteousness ... even if we should not.

You can fail, if the choice is to do so.
Or you can succeed, if that is your choice.
On this we agree. These are the only two choices that God has given us. People may try to walk along the top of the fence but eventually they will end up on one side or the other.
 
And I, brethren, could not speak unto you as unto spiritual, but as unto carnal, even as unto babes in Christ. I have fed you with milk, and not with meat: for hitherto ye were not able to bear it, neither yet now are ye able. For ye are yet carnal: for whereas there is among you envying, and strife, and divisions, are ye not carnal, and walk as men? 1Corinthians 3:1-3
 
Back
Top